M. J. ELLIS

Field note 003

My Cats Have No Interest in My Philosophy

I have questions about consciousness.

My cats have questions about dinner.

We both consider our questions urgent.

One of mine is how much of another creature’s experience I can ever understand. I can watch a cat, learn its habits, recognize when it wants something. But I can’t climb inside its experience and look out.

Meanwhile, the cat can apparently look at me and determine that I’m the idiot standing between it and an unopened bag of food.

There’s something humbling about that.

I spend a lot of time thinking about what it means to exist. A cat seems perfectly willing to exist while I’m still working on the question.

I don’t know whether cats think about death. I don’t know what time feels like to them, or whether a familiar room carries anything like the meaning it carries for me. I suspect there’s much more going on than I can see. I also suspect I’d misunderstand a good portion of it even if they could explain.

If a cat could speak, I might ask what it’s like to be a cat.

It might ask why I keep shutting doors.

Fair question. Difficult to defend, honestly.

Living with another kind of mind makes some of my grander ideas feel a little less grand. Here is a creature with preferences, routines, attachments, and a whole life happening from a perspective I will never occupy. We share a house. Sometimes we want different things from the same piece of furniture.

And somehow we work it out.

That interests me at least as much as any abstract argument about consciousness. You can know so little about what another being experiences and still learn how to make its day better.

A warm spot. A familiar voice. Knowing when to leave it alone.

I’d like to think my cats would appreciate this observation.

But I’ve now written several paragraphs without feeding anybody.

My credibility is collapsing.

Read next

What did this bring up for you?

A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.

Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.
Back to the journal