M. J. ELLIS

Field note 007

Someone Is in There

If you replaced Lilith with another cat that looked exactly like her, I would not consider the situation resolved.

I don’t think this is a particularly controversial statement.

Nobody who has loved an animal hears “We found you an identical one” and thinks, Excellent. All the relevant properties have been restored.

You might love the new animal. Eventually, you might love them just as much.

But you would still be looking for the one who was gone.

That seems like an interesting place to start a conversation about personhood.

Certainly more interesting than making a dolphin pass an exam.


I think animals can be persons.

That sentence tends to make people imagine a cat with a driver’s license, which is understandable. We’ve bundled an enormous amount of human business into the word person.

I’m using it to mean someone. A particular being whose life happens from their own side of it. Someone for whom things can go well or badly, whether or not they can explain the situation to me.

My cats have never explained much.

They have submitted numerous complaints.

There’s a difference.

I don’t think Lilith is a small human wearing a cat. I think she is Lilith, and being a cat is part of what that means. Her world presumably contains things I would struggle to understand, just as mine contains things she has no reason to care about.

Mortgage interest, for example.

I envy her that one.

But her failure to participate in my concerns doesn’t make her an empty room.


The word anthropomorphism usually arrives somewhere around here.

Fair enough. We can project human motives onto animals. We can misunderstand what they want because we’ve decided their behavior means whatever it would mean if a human did it.

Loving somebody does not make you automatically good at understanding them.

Ask anyone who has been married.

But we can make a mistake in the other direction, too. We can become so determined not to invent a human inside an animal that we refuse to acknowledge anyone inside at all.

I don’t know exactly what being a cat feels like.

I also don’t know what being you feels like.

You have the considerable advantage of being able to tell me. Even then, I’ve misunderstood people who were speaking very clearly, in my language, while pointing at the problem.

Access to another mind is imperfect. That should make us careful about our interpretations.

I don’t see why it should make us careless with the mind.


What keeps bringing me back to this is how particular they are.

Lilith is not interchangeable with Loki.

Knowing one doesn’t mean I know the other. A relationship has to be learned. What makes this one comfortable? When do they want company? What frightens them? What does trust look like coming from this particular creature?

Over time, you learn enough to notice when something changes.

You notice an absence, too.

When an animal dies, the house can still contain animals. There can still be food bowls, fur on the furniture, and somebody doing something expensive to the upholstery.

And yet the house is different.

A particular way of being alive has stopped moving through it.

That loss doesn’t prove every philosophical claim we might want to make about animals. My grief cannot tell me exactly how another creature experienced the world.

But it does make “just get another one” sound as inadequate as it is.

I loved that one.

The distinction was the whole relationship.


Of course, if I take this seriously, I can’t make personhood something my affection awards.

My cats don’t become someone because I know their names.

An animal I’ve never met doesn’t have less of an inner life because nobody has introduced us. And whatever makes a creature matter cannot depend entirely on whether I find it charming.

That’s where the thought gets uncomfortable.

It’s easy to recognize someone curled up beside you. Harder when recognizing them asks something of you.

I don’t have every implication worked out. I suspect having them worked out would require changes I haven’t fully faced.

But I don’t want to use my unfinished answer as an excuse to stop asking the question.

When I look at my cats, I think there is someone looking back.

Someone with a life I share a little of and understand even less.

Someone who doesn’t need to become more like me to have a claim on my consideration.

I can live with not knowing exactly what happens behind those eyes.

I have a harder time with deciding it doesn’t matter because they can’t tell me.

Read next

Explore a book

For a stranger conversation about grief, God, and being alive, read a sample of God’s Name Is Gerald.

What did this bring up for you?

A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.

Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.
Back to the journal