M. J. ELLIS

Field note 014

What If We're Not as Separate as We Think?

By M. J. Ellis

Here's a pretty convincing argument that you and I are separate beings.

If you stub your toe, I don't feel it.

There. Case closed. Thousands of years of philosophy, and we've solved the whole thing with a piece of furniture.

Except I'm not entirely sure we have.

Something occurred to me recently, and the more I thought about it, the more I wondered whether we're making an assumption that isn't necessarily true.

What if we actually can feel another person's pain, just not in the way we've been expecting to?

The Wrong Kind of Pain

Imagine watching someone you love get hurt.

Maybe your child falls and scrapes their knee. Maybe your partner receives terrible news. Maybe someone you care about is sitting across from you, trying desperately not to cry.

Something happens inside you.

Your stomach tightens. Your chest aches. You might even find yourself fighting back tears.

You haven't scraped your knee. You haven't received the terrible news. Whatever happened to that person hasn't physically happened to you.

And yet you're feeling something.

Something real.

We have a name for this.

Empathy.

We usually think of empathy as our ability to understand or share another person's feelings. It's part of what helps us care about each other and avoid being complete assholes.

But here's what got me thinking.

What if empathy isn't just how we understand someone else's pain? What if it's how we feel it?

Not in exactly the same way they do, obviously.

But through a different part of ourselves.

Maybe We're Asking the Wrong Question

Think about your senses for a moment.

Your eyes can't hear music.

Your ears can't see sunlight.

That doesn't mean music and sunlight aren't real. It just means you need different senses to experience them.

Now think about another person's pain.

If you break your arm, I don't feel your broken arm. My nerves aren't sending pain signals to my brain.

But if I see you suffering, I might feel terrible.

Your pain has affected me. I'm experiencing something because of what you're experiencing.

It's not the same sensation, but it is a real feeling.

So here's my question.

What if our inability to feel another person's pain in exactly the same way they do isn't proof that we're completely separate?

What if we're simply expecting to feel it through the wrong system?

It's a little like saying two people aren't connected because they don't share the same pair of eyes.

Of course they don't.

But does that tell us everything about their connection?

I'm not so sure.

Before Somebody Starts Selling Crystals

I should probably clarify something.

I'm not saying empathy proves we're all part of one giant consciousness.

It doesn't.

Science has perfectly reasonable explanations for empathy. Our brains are wired to recognize and respond to other people's emotions. We can imagine what someone else is going through, and that can produce real feelings of our own.

Nothing supernatural is required.

But I'm not really questioning the science of empathy.

I'm questioning what we assume it tells us about ourselves.

We know we're individuals. We know we each experience the world from our own point of view.

But does having your own point of view necessarily mean you're completely separate from everything else?

Maybe.

Maybe not.

And that's really the point of this whole thought.

Sometimes we mistake the way we experience something for the way that thing actually is.

Our perspective feels complete because it's the only one we've ever had.

But feeling certain about something doesn't necessarily make it true.

And Then There's God

This is where my mind wandered into religion.

There's a recurring idea in many spiritual traditions that human beings are somehow separated from God, or from a greater whole.

Different religions have very different explanations for what that means.

But what if the separation is something we experience rather than something that actually exists?

Imagine, just for a moment, that we're all connected to something larger.

Call it God. Call it a shared existence. Call it whatever you like.

Now imagine that each of us experiences that existence through our own individual mind.

Wouldn't we feel separate?

We'd look out through our own eyes. Hear our own thoughts. Feel our own pain.

We'd naturally assume that the little world happening inside our heads was entirely our own.

But every once in a while, something strange happens.

Someone else's sadness makes us sad.

Someone else's happiness makes us happy.

We love someone so deeply that what happens to them can feel almost as important as what happens to us.

For a moment, the line between their experience and our experience doesn't seem quite so clear.

Now suppose that separation from God isn't necessarily a connection that's been broken.

Maybe it's a connection we simply don't recognize.

Maybe empathy, love, and compassion are little reminders of something we're usually too wrapped up in ourselves to notice.

Or maybe they're just wonderful things our brains evolved to do.

Either possibility is interesting to me.

What If Your Perspective Is Wrong?

Here's the thing.

I don't think we're going to get a definite answer to this question.

We can't exactly run an experiment that proves everyone is secretly part of the same consciousness because someone cried during a sad movie.

And I'm certainly not suggesting we should build an entire belief system around a random thought I had.

But I think there's value in asking questions that don't necessarily have answers.

Especially when they make us examine something we've always taken for granted.

We go through life trusting our own perspective. We almost have to. It's how we make sense of everything.

But our perspective is limited.

We only see what our eyes can see. We only hear what our ears can hear. We only know what our minds are capable of understanding.

And we spend our entire lives inside that little window, often assuming it gives us a pretty accurate picture of reality.

What if it doesn't?

What if some of the things we're most certain about are simply the things we've never thought to question?

I'm not suggesting that we're all secretly one person. I rather like being me, and I assume you enjoy being you at least some of the time.

I'm just wondering whether being individuals necessarily means being as separate as we feel.

And whether empathy might be worth looking at a little differently.

Maybe it doesn't tell us anything mysterious about the universe.

Maybe it tells us something extraordinary about being human.

Either way, thinking about it has made me a little less certain that my experience of the world is the whole story.

And perhaps that's enough.

We don't have to solve the mystery of consciousness or establish the existence of God to get something out of the question.

Sometimes the most interesting thing a thought can do is make you realize that what seems obvious isn't necessarily what is true.

So the next time someone says, "You can't feel my pain," maybe there's another way to think about it.

Not the way you do.

But that doesn't mean I can't feel you.

Read next

Explore a book

For a closer look at perception and the assumptions behind experience, read a sample of The Book You Are Not Supposed to Finish.

What did this bring up for you?

A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.

Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.
Back to the journal