Field note 021
Your Worst Day Is Still Your Worst Day
By M. J. Ellis
There's a sentence people reach for when someone is hurting.
"It could be worse."
Which is true. Almost everything could be worse. You could lose your job, your car could break down, and on the walk home you could be attacked by a goose with a personal grievance.
The universe has an extraordinary imagination when it comes to making a bad day worse.
But I've never understood why knowing someone else is suffering more is supposed to make your suffering disappear.
Somebody else's broken leg doesn't make your broken finger stop hurting.
And pointing that out doesn't mean a broken finger and a broken leg are equally serious. Of course they aren't. Circumstances differ. Consequences differ. Some people need help more urgently than others.
But your worst day is still your worst day.
There isn't a cosmic leaderboard that invalidates your pain because someone else has scored higher.
The View from Somewhere Else
Imagine a small child who thinks their parent has disappeared.
The parent knows they're only in the next room. They know the child is safe. They know they'll be back in a minute.
The child doesn't know any of that.
For the child, the fear is real.
The parent's wider perspective doesn't make the child's experience imaginary. If anything, it gives the parent a reason to be gentle.
Two perspectives on the same event. Very different scales of understanding. Neither requires us to pretend the child isn't frightened.
I've been thinking about that while reading Manly P. Hall and his accounts of ancient religious mysteries.
Some traditions describe our individual existence as a kind of separation from a greater divine unity. The separation brings ignorance, loneliness, suffering, and death. Spiritual liberation is imagined as a return to the whole.
I can see the appeal.
No separation, no fear of losing anyone. No grief. No being a fragile creature on a planet that seems determined to invent new things to worry about.
But I keep getting stuck on something.
If there were no distinction between you and another person, who would there be to love?
The Trouble with Being Someone
I don't think love is just recognizing yourself in someone else.
I think part of its beauty is recognizing someone who is not you.
Someone with a life you can share but never completely possess. Someone who can surprise you, disagree with you, make you laugh, and sometimes break your heart.
That difference makes relationship possible.
It also makes loss possible.
So yes, individuality opens the door to suffering. But I hesitate to conclude that individuality is therefore a mistake.
The fact that loving someone makes me vulnerable to losing them doesn't make me wish they had never existed.
And it certainly doesn't mean every terrible thing that happens to someone was necessary, deserved, or secretly good for them.
I don't believe we need to justify suffering to recognize the value of love.
What Would God's Worst Day Look Like?
Here's where this gets theological. Sorry. We were doing so well pretending this was a normal conversation.
Here's the possibility I've been wrestling with.
When I spend time with someone I love, I'm not doing it because I need to learn something about them. Sometimes we talk. Sometimes we say absolutely nothing. I simply want to share the experience of being alive with them.
The being together is the point.
Now imagine, just for a moment, that what we call God isn't a distant observer watching existence unfold, but the Source from which existence comes. What if our individual lives are ways that Source participates in existence?
That wouldn't mean you or I are God in our entirety. We'd still be ourselves. We'd still be different from one another. And perhaps that difference is precisely what makes love possible. There has to be someone other to encounter.
In that picture, creation wouldn't be God trying to learn something or solve a problem. It would be more like sharing a life with someone you love.
Not because something is missing.
Because being together is worth something all by itself.
And that makes me wonder about suffering.
Would the size of a consciousness change how it experiences pain?
My worst day is experienced within the limits of my life. Someone else's worst day is experienced within theirs. A divine awareness, if such a thing exists, might encounter those experiences within a scope I can't begin to imagine.
But broader doesn't have to mean shallower.
Think of the child and the parent again.
The parent understands more. The child's fear is still real. Love is what makes the larger perspective respond rather than dismiss.
If God participates in existence through love, perhaps divine understanding isn't a way of standing above our suffering and declaring it insignificant.
Perhaps it would mean that our suffering is not beneath notice.
I don't know whether God exists, much less what God experiences. A meaningful analogy isn't proof. And a grand perspective would not excuse neglect, cruelty, or injustice down here where the pain actually happens.
But I find this possibility more compelling than imagining the universe as one enormous spiritual waiting room, with everyone suffering until they're finally allowed to leave.
Nobody Gets to Tell You It Doesn't Hurt
Sometimes a larger perspective helps. It can remind us that a painful moment isn't the whole of our lives, just as our lives aren't the whole of existence.
But that's different from telling someone their pain doesn't count.
We can hold both truths at once: the universe is unimaginably vast, and the thing happening to you right now matters.
Your grief doesn't become trivial because stars are exploding somewhere. Your joy doesn't become trivial because the galaxies don't notice it, either.
And if love is participation in another's existence, then perhaps the right response to suffering isn't always an explanation.
Sometimes it's simply refusing to leave someone alone with it.
I don't know whether there's a God capable of holding every perspective at once.
But if there is, I hope seeing the whole universe makes God more capable of noticing one person's worst day.
Not less.
Read next
Explore a book
For a stranger conversation about grief, God, and being alive, read a sample of God’s Name Is Gerald.
What did this bring up for you?
A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.
Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.