Field note 020
I’ve Heard Some Things About You
By M. J. Ellis
Sometimes I wonder whether we let other people’s ideas about God get in the way of having a relationship with God.
Him. Her. They. Thou.
I’m willing to work out the pronouns if we ever get introduced.
But that’s part of the problem.
By the time most of us are old enough to wonder about God, the introductions have already been handled.
Someone has told us who God is, what God wants, what makes God angry, and which people God finds disappointing.
Occasionally, those people are everyone in the neighboring building.
God apparently has very strong opinions about where the chairs go.
And somewhere beneath all that information, there might be a question we haven’t had much room to ask.
Who are you?
Someone Handed Me a Picture
Imagine being told about someone your entire life.
Some people say they’re loving.
Others say they’re dangerous.
One person says they’ll forgive anything. Another hands you a surprisingly detailed list of exceptions.
Someone insists they’re always available.
Someone else says you need an authorized intermediary.
At a certain point, you might reasonably decide that meeting this person sounds exhausting.
And you haven’t even met them.
You’ve met their reputation.
I think something like that can happen with God.
Someone hands us a picture and says, “This is God.”
Maybe the picture is beautiful. Maybe it helps us feel less alone. Maybe it gives us a way to understand love, grief, forgiveness, or the strange fact that anything exists at all.
But maybe there’s something in the picture we cannot accept.
Cruelty presented as justice.
Fear presented as love.
A demand that we stop asking questions at precisely the point where the questions become important.
And rejecting that picture can feel like rejecting every possibility of a relationship.
As though the only available choices are to accept the description or conclude there’s nobody to meet.
I’m not sure those are the only choices.
The People Who Gave Us the Words
I don’t want to pretend we can approach this without anything we’ve learned from other people.
Even the word God arrived here before we did.
Other people’s ideas can be gifts.
Someone writes a prayer that says what we couldn’t say.
Someone describes an experience that makes us think, “Wait. You’ve felt that too?”
A tradition gives us somewhere to stand while the rest of our life seems determined to become structurally unsound.
There’s value in that.
I’m grateful that people have spent centuries trying to find language for things that are difficult to discuss over lunch.
But I think there’s a difference between someone saying:
“Here’s how I’ve understood it.”
And someone saying:
“Here’s what you’re allowed to find.”
The first makes room for a conversation.
The second makes me suspect there will be a form.
I’ve Heard Some Fairly Troubling Things
If I ever had the opportunity to speak directly with God, I don’t think I’d begin with a particularly impressive prayer.
I’d probably say something like:
“I’ve heard some fairly troubling things about you. I’d rather hear your side.”
Which might sound disrespectful.
But to me, there’s something deeply respectful about wanting to meet someone beyond what other people have said about them.
Especially when the reports conflict quite this dramatically.
I’ve heard that God is love.
I’ve also heard God described in ways that would make me reluctant to leave a cat in his care.
I don’t know how to reconcile those descriptions by pretending they sound alike.
And if there is a God who knows me completely, I doubt there’s much point in concealing the confusion.
Presumably, the confusion is already visible.
Along with whatever else I was hoping we wouldn’t get into during the first meeting.
A Relationship Has Room for Questions
When I think about the relationships that matter to me, they involve discovery.
I don’t know everything about the other person before the relationship begins.
I learn.
Sometimes I misunderstand them.
Sometimes I have to reconsider something I thought I knew.
Sometimes they surprise me.
It would be strange to insist that a relationship with God must begin only after all the important questions have been settled.
Who exactly are you?
What are you made of?
What happened before the universe?
Please account for suffering.
Also, I have some concerns about the ocean.
Those are real questions.
Well. The ocean one may be more personal.
But I wonder whether we sometimes make complete understanding a condition of even reaching out.
As though we must finish the biography before we’re allowed to say hello.
I don’t know what God is.
I don’t know whether what or who is the better word.
But uncertainty doesn’t make the longing disappear.
And I don’t think pretending to be certain would make the reaching more honest.
I Don’t Want to Invent Someone Who Always Agrees With Me
There’s a difficulty here, of course.
If I question everyone else’s picture of God, I could simply replace it with a picture that flatters me.
A God who shares my opinions.
Appreciates my reasoning.
Finds my enemies tiresome.
Understands that my shortcomings require context, while other people’s shortcomings are fairly straightforward.
That would be convenient.
Suspiciously convenient.
So I don’t think “find your own relationship” can mean “assume every feeling you have is a message from the universe.”
I’ve had powerful feelings that turned out to mean I needed lunch.
My own interpretations deserve questions too.
If I’m going to leave room for an encounter, I have to leave room for being wrong about what I encounter.
For hearing something I didn’t want to hear.
For discovering that the person I’ve dismissed has something to teach me.
For love asking more of me than agreeing that love is a lovely idea.
I wouldn’t expect a meaningful relationship to leave every comfortable assumption undisturbed.
Maybe We Can Start Honestly
Some people have found a relationship with God through religion.
Some have found room to reach out only after leaving it.
Some are still standing in the doorway, unsure whether they want to enter or whether they’ll be welcome.
And some have been hurt badly enough that they need distance.
I wouldn’t ask anyone to call that hurt a gift or rush back toward something that frightened them.
But if there’s still a part of you that wonders—beneath the arguments, the disappointment, the things you were told you had to believe—I don’t think you need an impressive opening statement.
Maybe it’s:
“I don’t know whether anyone is listening.”
Maybe it’s:
“I’m angry.”
Maybe it’s:
“I miss something I’m not sure I’ve ever known.”
Those seem like honest places to begin.
Perhaps more honest than borrowing words that sound beautiful while hiding everything we actually came to say.
I keep imagining how much of the conversation might change if we gave ourselves permission to admit that we don’t know who we’re talking to yet.
To listen without deciding in advance what every silence means.
To wonder without immediately recruiting the answer into an argument.
To let something remain possible.
I don’t know what would come of that.
But if I ever do manage an introduction, I hope I can put down the pictures long enough to look.
“I’ve heard a lot about you.
“Some of it made me want to find you.
“Some of it made me afraid to try.
“I’d like to start again.
“Hello.”
Read next
Explore a book
For a stranger conversation about grief, God, and being alive, read a sample of God’s Name Is Gerald.
What did this bring up for you?
A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.
Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.