Field note 018
The Monster Was Better Before I Named It
By M. J. Ellis
The fastest way to make a monster less frightening is to explain what it is.
There are exceptions, obviously.
If the monster is a bear, for example, identifying it as a bear might be useful information. Particularly if you're standing between it and something it considers lunch.
But I'm talking about fictional monsters.
The things that live in the dark. The things that knock when nobody's outside. The things that look almost human until they do something no human being should be capable of doing.
Those things.
I've noticed that the moment we explain them, something changes.
The thing in the basement becomes a demon.
The demon becomes a particular kind of demon.
The particular kind of demon has weaknesses, habits, a history, and a surprisingly detailed entry on a fan-maintained wiki.
Congratulations.
The unspeakable horror now has a character sheet.
And somehow, it's not quite as frightening anymore.
I Used to Write Songs About Things I Refused to Identify
Years ago, I was the vocalist and one of the principal writers for a death metal band.
We weren't writing songs about finding ourselves during a weekend in Vermont.
One of those songs was called "The Shroud."
When I wrote it, I had a very specific creature in mind.
A lich.
For anyone unfamiliar, a lich is generally an undead sorcerer who has preserved some form of existence beyond death, often through profoundly unpleasant magical arrangements.
They're wonderful monsters.
And I never used the word lich in the song.
Not once.
I didn't want the listener to hear the lyrics and think, "Oh, okay. A lich."
Because the moment that happened, the listener would stop encountering something strange and start recognizing something familiar.
I wanted the creature to speak for itself.
To reveal its nature through its perspective, its desires, and the terrible implications of what it had become.
The audience didn't need the label.
In fact, I thought the label would make the whole thing a little corny.
Which is an interesting concern for someone performing death metal.
Apparently, I was comfortable with supernatural damnation, occult imagery, and unspeakable horrors.
But I drew the line at sounding like I was reading from a Dungeons & Dragons manual.
We all have standards.
The Thing You Summon Might Not Be Interested in Negotiating
Another song, "I Call Down Horrors," came from a similar place.
I was imagining something Lovecraftian.
Ancient, incomprehensible entities that exist so far outside the human frame of reference that our concepts of good, evil, mercy, and negotiation might be completely meaningless to them.
The song involves someone calling upon those forces.
And the summoner believes he can bargain.
He is willing to accept enslavement if it means continuing to exist.
Which is a fairly desperate negotiating position.
But I always suspected he had misunderstood the arrangement.
Not the fine print.
The entire concept of an arrangement.
He's imagining a transaction between two parties who recognize one another as participants.
The entities may not recognize him as anything at all.
Imagine an ant offering you its eternal servitude in exchange for not stepping on it.
You probably wouldn't consider the proposal.
You might not even know the ant was making one.
Now imagine the ant has built an elaborate temple, performed a ritual, and written several thousand lines of poetry about your magnificent power.
You still might step on it.
Not because you're evil.
Because you're walking to the refrigerator.
That's the kind of cosmic horror I find interesting.
And again, I didn't need to name the entities.
Naming them would have made the universe smaller.
The important thing wasn't which particular horror answered the call.
It was the possibility that nothing answering the call could ever understand the caller in the way he desperately needed it to.
A Name Gives the Audience Something to Hold
I think names do something psychologically useful.
They give us handles.
When we encounter something unfamiliar, identifying it helps us decide what to do next.
A noise in the woods is frightening.
A raccoon in the woods is considerably less frightening.
Unless the raccoon is standing upright, wearing your grandfather's wedding suit, and quietly reciting your Social Security number.
Then we're back to having a problem.
But generally, classification makes the world manageable.
We encounter something strange.
We assign it a category.
We retrieve everything we know about that category.
And the unknown becomes a little less unknown.
This is an extraordinary human ability.
It's also why explaining a fictional monster too thoroughly can destroy the very effect the writer was trying to create.
The reader stops asking, "What the hell is happening?"
And starts asking, "What are the rules?"
Rules aren't necessarily bad.
In some stories, they're essential.
A monster with clearly established limitations can create wonderful suspense. If we know it cannot cross running water, then watching someone struggle toward a river can be terrifying.
But that's a different kind of fear.
It's the fear of a known danger.
The fear I'm talking about comes from realizing that the categories themselves may be inadequate.
That the thing in front of you doesn't fit.
That every explanation you reach for makes less sense than the last.
And that whatever it is, it doesn't particularly care whether you understand it.
The Monster Doesn't Need a Biography
There's a peculiar temptation in writing to explain everything.
Where did the monster come from?
Why does it behave this way?
What does it want?
What are its weaknesses?
Was it always evil?
Did something happen to it as a child?
Did its father neglect it?
Is the unspeakable horror actually struggling with unresolved abandonment issues?
Sometimes those questions produce a better story.
Sometimes they produce a three-season streaming series in which the creature that once made audiences afraid to turn off the lights now has a complicated relationship with its mother.
I'm not opposed to sympathetic monsters.
Some of the best monsters are tragic.
But not every horror needs to be understood.
And not every explanation is an improvement.
Consider how much of our fear comes from intention.
If something is chasing you because it's hungry, you understand the situation.
You might still be terrified, but you understand it.
If something is chasing you because it loves you, things become considerably stranger.
And if something is following you, but you cannot determine whether it knows you're there, whether it's alive, or whether the concept of following even applies to what it's doing?
Now you've got my attention.
The absence of explanation isn't automatically frightening, of course.
A writer can't simply refuse to answer every question and expect the audience to applaud the mystery.
That's not cosmic horror.
That's poor customer service.
The trick is giving the reader enough to experience the impossible without giving them enough to make it ordinary.
I Think the Reader Should Have to Participate
This is something I've carried from music into fiction.
When I wrote lyrics, I didn't want to stop the song and explain the creature.
I wanted the listener to assemble it from what the creature said.
Now, when I'm writing fiction, I find myself drawn to the same approach.
In God's Name Is Gerald, a man claims to be God.
That's an enormous claim.
And one of the central pleasures of the premise, at least for me, is that the reader doesn't receive a convenient certificate of authenticity.
Gerald has to speak.
He has to argue.
He has to be funny, irritating, insightful, contradictory, and occasionally convincing.
The reader has to decide what to make of him.
If I settled the question for everyone, I would be taking away part of the experience.
The same instinct shows up in the horror stories I'm developing for The Bad Neighborhoods of Reality.
The premise allows me to open curtains onto realities where something has gone terribly wrong.
Sometimes the horror is physical.
Sometimes it's psychological.
Sometimes the universe itself appears to have made an administrative error.
But I'm increasingly convinced that the most disturbing stories aren't necessarily the ones with the largest monsters.
They're the ones that leave the reader with a question their mind keeps trying to answer.
And failing.
Not because the writer forgot to explain something.
Because the explanation might be worse.
Or because there may not be an explanation that fits inside a human mind.
The Audience Is Usually Better at Frightening Itself
Here's the strange thing.
If I describe a monster in exhaustive detail, I give you my monster.
Its height.
Its teeth.
Its skin.
Its movements.
Its smell.
Every revolting little anatomical innovation I managed to invent while sitting at a keyboard.
And maybe it's horrifying.
But if I give you a few carefully chosen details and leave the rest alone, something else happens.
You start building it.
You fill in the missing pieces with things I couldn't possibly know about you.
Your memories.
Your fears.
The shapes that made you uncomfortable when you were a child.
That thing you thought you saw standing in the hallway when you woke up at three in the morning.
You know the one.
The one that disappeared when you turned on the light.
I can't write that creature as effectively as you can imagine it.
Because yours belongs to you.
And when a story leaves the right spaces empty, the reader becomes an unwilling collaborator.
The writer supplies the doorway.
The reader supplies whatever is standing behind it.
That's a partnership I find much more interesting than explaining every last detail.
But Mystery Has to Earn Its Place
There's a difference between withholding information and having nothing to say.
I think that's important.
If a story presents a mystery, builds toward an answer, and then refuses to provide one simply because the writer couldn't think of anything satisfying, the audience has every right to be annoyed.
Mystery isn't a substitute for structure.
Ambiguity isn't a substitute for meaning.
And incomprehensibility isn't automatically profound.
Sometimes a confusing story is just confusing.
I've probably written a few of those myself.
But I think a writer should understand the emotional purpose of what remains unexplained.
What does the reader need to know?
What would knowing destroy?
What uncertainty makes the experience more powerful?
And what uncertainty merely makes the story harder to follow?
Those are different questions.
The monster can remain unidentified while its effect on the characters becomes painfully clear.
We may never know what the thing wants.
But we should understand what it costs someone to encounter it.
We may never learn where it came from.
But we should feel the consequences of its arrival.
The mystery should deepen the experience.
Not excuse the absence of one.
The Thing Behind the Curtain
I still love monsters.
The grotesque ones.
The impossible ones.
The ones with too many limbs, too many teeth, or an entirely unreasonable number of eyes.
I love the theatricality of horror.
The curtain rising.
The audience leaning forward.
The moment everyone realizes that whatever they've been waiting to see is considerably worse than they expected.
But the older I get, the more interested I become in what happens before the curtain opens.
That moment when you know something is behind it.
You can hear it moving.
Maybe you can see its outline.
Maybe somebody standing beside you recognizes the shape and begins crying.
And you haven't seen a thing.
Not really.
Your imagination is already doing terrible work.
Which brings me back to those old songs.
The lich didn't need to announce what it was.
The cosmic entities didn't need names.
And the thing behind the curtain doesn't necessarily need to explain itself.
Sometimes giving the monster a name is exactly what makes it manageable.
Sometimes understanding something is the first step toward no longer fearing it.
And sometimes the most frightening possibility is that the thing you've encountered cannot be understood at all.
So I'll keep writing monsters.
I'll give them voices, movements, appetites, and the occasional deeply unpleasant physical characteristic.
But I think I'll let some of them keep their secrets.
Because the monster I can explain is the monster I've already made smaller.
And whatever is standing behind that curtain?
I'd rather you meet it before I tell you what to call it.
Probably Nothing — M. J. Ellis
Strange questions. Uncomfortable answers. Occasional profanity.
Read next
What did this bring up for you?
A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.
Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.