Field note 024
Pythagoras Would Have Hated My Band
By M. J. Ellis
I recently found myself studying Pythagoras, which is not something I expected to be doing voluntarily.
I hate math.
I've hated math for as long as I can remember. Numbers have always struck me as an unnecessarily complicated way of communicating information that could probably be conveyed with a drawing or a reasonably expressive grunt.
Which is interesting, considering I spent part of my life making death metal.
For those unfamiliar with the genre, death metal is a form of music in which several people work very hard to produce a sound resembling a malfunctioning industrial facility being attacked by demons.
I used to front a death metal band. I won't name it. You've probably never heard of it anyway, and the writing here is of a decidedly different flavor from the lyrics in our liner notes.
We had the growling vocals, the distorted guitars, the blast beats, the whole thing. I wrote lyrics about some fairly unpleasant subjects and contributed heavily to the music responsible for delivering them.
To the uninitiated, it probably sounded like we were trying to kill something.
We were, in fact, making music.
And apparently, Pythagoras had something to say about how that works.
The Greek Guy With the Numbers
Pythagoras lived roughly 2,500 years ago, and the philosophical tradition associated with him became famous for finding simple numerical relationships in musical harmony.
There's a famous story about him passing a blacksmith's shop, hearing different hammers striking anvils, and realizing that the sounds corresponded to mathematical ratios.
It's a lovely story.
It also almost certainly didn't happen that way.
But the underlying discovery is real.
When a vibrating string is shortened to half its length, its pitch rises by an octave, assuming its tension remains the same.
Other simple relationships produce familiar musical intervals, including the perfect fifth.
In other words, there is actual mathematical structure hiding inside the sounds we hear.
Two notes don't sound harmonious together because the universe has good taste.
They have physical relationships that our auditory systems interpret in particular ways.
The Pythagoreans found this fascinating.
They began entertaining the possibility that the universe itself operated according to similar principles.
The harmony of the spheres. Cosmic order. Reality as an arrangement of mathematical relationships.
Meanwhile, a couple of millennia later, somebody invented the distortion pedal, and things got considerably less polite.
The Mathematics of Being Unpleasant
Here's something people who don't listen to extreme metal often misunderstand.
The music isn't random.
In fact, some of it requires a rather ridiculous degree of precision.
A drummer playing a blast beat is coordinating rapid, repeated movements across multiple limbs while maintaining a consistent pulse.
A guitarist might be playing tightly synchronized rhythmic patterns at a speed where small mistakes become immediately noticeable.
Add a bassist following the riff, another guitarist playing a complementary part, and a vocalist attempting to sound like a prehistoric animal regurgitating lunch for its offspring.
Everybody has to know exactly where they are.
Otherwise, you don't get death metal.
You get five people falling down the stairs at approximately the same time.
And the guitars themselves are doing something interesting.
A lot of heavy metal uses power chords, which typically consist of a root note and its fifth, sometimes with the octave added.
Remember Pythagoras?
That fifth was one of the mathematical relationships that fascinated the Pythagoreans.
It's especially useful in heavily distorted guitar music. Distortion introduces additional harmonics, and complicated chords can quickly turn into a muddy mess. The relatively simple structure of a power chord helps it maintain its identity through all that electrical abuse.
So one of the foundational sounds of heavy metal relies on an interval that ancient Greek thinkers considered an example of musical harmony.
We just run it through enough amplification to frighten the neighbors.
Sometimes the Ugly Part Is the Point
Of course, death metal doesn't rely exclusively on harmonious intervals.
Quite the opposite.
Dissonance is enormously useful.
Put certain notes close together, and they create tension. They rub against one another. The resulting sound can feel unstable, uncomfortable, or downright hostile.
Which is excellent news when you're writing a song about an ancient horror emerging from the void.
But here's the important part.
The dissonance isn't necessarily a failure of harmony.
It's another relationship.
And it can become meaningful through its relationship with everything surrounding it.
A nasty, dissonant riff can make the next passage sound enormous when it finally resolves.
A frantic section can make a sudden slowdown feel like the ground has opened beneath you.
A moment of silence can become the heaviest part of an entire song.
Think about that last one.
Silence.
The complete absence of musical sound.
Placed in the right relationship to what comes before and after it, silence can practically knock the wind out of an audience.
Try explaining that to somebody who thinks music is simply a collection of notes.
The Part the Numbers Don't Explain
Now, I don't want to take anything away from Pythagoras.
Discovering that musical intervals could be described through measurable relationships was an extraordinary achievement of ancient musical thought.
We can measure frequencies.
We can analyze rhythmic subdivisions.
We can describe harmonic structures, distortion, timing, and the physical behavior of vibrating strings.
We can probably explain why your car's speakers are making that noise.
What interests me is what happens when we finish explaining all of those things.
Because you can explain every note in a death metal song without explaining why someone loves it.
You can explain the timing of a breakdown without fully explaining the feeling of being in the crowd when it hits.
You can measure the sound coming out of a guitar amplifier.
You can't find the experience of playing that riff by opening the amplifier and looking around inside.
And I know this from experience.
There were moments onstage when everything locked together.
The drums, the guitars, the vocals, the audience.
Every so often, I'd look over at James, our lead guitarist, and we'd exchange a grin. A particular riff or crushing section was coming, and we both knew exactly what it was about to do to the room.
We didn't need to say anything.
We just knew.
And when it hit, there was nothing quite like it.
Nobody was thinking about mathematical ratios.
Nobody was solving for anything.
We were participating in something that existed only because all those individual parts were happening together.
And then the song ended.
The sound was gone.
But something had happened.
Something real.
A Little Order in the Chaos
Maybe that's what I find most interesting about the Pythagorean tradition.
It recognized that something we experience as a whole could contain relationships precise enough to measure.
And it was right.
But knowing the measurements doesn't exhaust the experience.
The same riff can be irritating noise to one person and the greatest thing they've ever heard to another.
They're hearing the same collection of frequencies.
But they aren't having the same experience.
One person's noise is another person's revelation.
And that depends on more than the notes themselves. It depends on who's listening, what they've lived through, what they associate with the sound, and what happens in that particular moment.
Those relationships can become something else when they're experienced.
Something angry.
Something joyful.
Something terrifying.
Something beautiful.
Sometimes all four at once.
I suspect Pythagoras would have been fascinated by the mechanics of death metal, even if he didn't particularly care for the results.
He might have recognized the relationships beneath the distortion.
He might even have appreciated the precision.
Although I'm fairly certain he'd have asked us to turn it down.
And there's something wonderfully satisfying about imagining a philosopher who searched for the mathematical harmony of the universe standing in a sweaty club, surrounded by people enthusiastically headbanging to music that sounds like the universe is coming apart.
Because beneath all that noise, the relationships are still there.
Even chaos can have excellent timing.
Read next
What did this bring up for you?
A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.
Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.