M. J. ELLIS

Field note 030

The One Day Everybody Dresses Like Me

By M. J. Ellis

My wife calls it spooky season.

I call it the one time of year everybody dresses like me.

For approximately twenty-four hours, the rest of the population finally catches up. Black clothing becomes festive. Skulls are considered appropriate home decor. Looking like you might know something about a cemetery is suddenly a desirable quality.

Then November arrives, everybody puts their normal clothes back on, and I'm left wondering why we're abandoning such a promising direction.

Halloween has always been my favorite holiday.

I love the horror movies, the decorations, the ridiculous costumes, the atmosphere. I love that somewhere in America right now, a grown man is spending $400 and three weekends building a mechanical corpse to frighten a child who just wanted a miniature Snickers.

I respect that kind of commitment.

But the older I get, the more fascinated I become with Halloween's history.

Because before it became an annual celebration of inflatable skeletons and pumpkin-spice everything, Halloween was considerably weirder.

And occasionally much more disturbing.

For example, our beloved jack-o'-lantern was originally a turnip.

Not a pumpkin.

A turnip.

In Ireland, people carved frightening faces into turnips, hollowed them out, and placed lights inside. The National Museum of Ireland even has a model of an old ghost turnip from County Donegal.

If you've never seen one, look it up.

The thing looks like it was discovered beneath a church during an exorcism.

Our modern pumpkins are practically friendly by comparison. They've got big smiles and adorable triangular eyes. You can put one on your porch and reasonably expect a toddler to wave at it.

The Irish turnip looks like it's been dead for six hundred years and has some very specific complaints.

And there's an entire story behind the lantern.

According to one Irish folktale, a fellow called Stingy Jack managed to trick the Devil. More than once, depending on the telling.

When Jack finally died, Heaven wouldn't take him. Hell wouldn't take him either, because he'd already negotiated himself out of the Devil's custody.

So Jack was left to wander the darkness with a burning ember inside a hollowed-out turnip.

Imagine being such a pain in the ass that even Satan checks the paperwork and says, "Absolutely not."

I love that story.

I also love that somewhere along the way, Americans took one look at the terrifying little root vegetable and decided the tradition would be improved by using something roughly the size of a basketball.

Fair enough.

But that's just the vegetable situation.

Halloween also used to be a major occasion for predicting your romantic future.

Which seems strange now, because I generally associate Halloween romance with somebody dressed as a sexy vampire getting into an argument with a man wearing an inflatable dinosaur.

Historically, though, people took this stuff seriously.

In Scotland, one old custom involved going into a garden at night, closing your eyes, and pulling up a stalk of kale.

The length and shape of the stalk supposedly revealed something about your future spouse's appearance. The amount of dirt clinging to the roots could indicate how wealthy they'd be.

That's right.

At one point in human history, people were consulting kale about their marriage prospects.

Imagine trying to explain to your grandchildren how you met.

"Well, your grandmother and I were destined for each other. I pulled a particularly filthy vegetable out of the ground, and the rest is history."

Other traditions involved throwing nuts into fires to see whether a relationship would succeed.

If they burned peacefully, things looked promising.

If they hissed and cracked, trouble was coming.

To be fair, I've known a few relationships that could have benefited from an early warning system involving burning chestnuts.

But my favorite old Halloween romantic custom may be the mirror.

In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, people practiced a variety of fortune-telling games involving mirrors, candles, and apples.

One involved sitting alone in a dark room, eating an apple by candlelight, and waiting for the face of your future husband to appear over your shoulder in the mirror.

I would like to point out that this is also a perfectly reasonable opening scene for a horror movie.

Because if I'm sitting alone in a dark room and another face appears behind mine in a mirror, I am no longer particularly concerned about whether we're compatible.

I have more immediate questions.

Like whether I remembered to lock the door.

And whether the face is still there when I turn around.

And whether my apple has somehow become relevant to the situation.

People really did this sort of thing for fun.

We used to have some outstanding hobbies.

Halloween wasn't always the relatively controlled neighborhood candy exchange we know today, either.

For a while, the trick part of trick-or-treating was taken considerably more seriously.

People pulled pranks. They overturned outhouses. They let livestock loose.

In Anoka, Minnesota, local accounts describe Halloween mischief so extensive that the town organized a community celebration in 1920 partly to give the troublemakers something less destructive to do.

Apparently, cows had been wandering around Main Street.

Try to picture being the mayor of a town and discovering that your seasonal public-safety problem involves unauthorized cattle.

"What happened last night?"

"Halloween, sir."

"Any injuries?"

"Not yet. But we've got three cows downtown and somebody's toilet is in a tree."

The solution was essentially to give everybody a parade.

And it worked well enough that Anoka went on to become known as the Halloween Capital of the World.

Which means one of America's great civic traditions owes at least part of its existence to people who couldn't be trusted around outhouses.

Beautiful.

Even trick-or-treating itself has some wonderfully peculiar ancestors.

In parts of Ireland and Scotland, costumed visitors went from house to house performing songs, poems, jokes, or other little entertainments in exchange for treats.

Elsewhere, a custom called souling involved people receiving food in exchange for prayers for the dead.

So we've gone from offering prayers for departed relatives to a six-year-old Spider-Man standing on your porch demanding chocolate.

I don't necessarily consider that a decline.

But I do think the next generation should have to perform something.

A short poem, perhaps.

Maybe a magic trick.

Nothing elaborate. Just enough to justify the full-size candy bar.

Of course, Halloween reaches much further back than any of those customs.

Its history is tangled up with Samhain, the Gaelic festival marking the transition into winter, and with Christian observances honoring saints and the dead.

The details are complicated, and anyone claiming to know exactly what every ancient celebration looked like is probably exercising more confidence than the evidence warrants.

But the recurring idea is fascinating.

A time when the ordinary world was thought to be a little less secure.

When spirits might wander.

When disguises mattered.

When the dead didn't seem quite as far away as they usually did.

I can see why that idea survived.

There's something about autumn that makes the whole arrangement feel plausible.

The trees start dropping their leaves. The days grow shorter. Things that were alive a few weeks ago are now lying in the street, making that dry scraping noise when the wind moves them.

It's what the Misfits called brown-leafed vertigo.

And I have never heard a better description of it.

Everything gets a little skeletal.

A little quieter.

The year starts looking like it's preparing to leave without saying goodbye.

And for one night, we respond by putting skeletons in the yard, carving faces into vegetables, and handing candy to small strangers dressed as monsters.

I don't know who first decided that was an appropriate response to the approach of winter.

But I like the way they think.

Tomorrow night, there will be ghosts walking down suburban sidewalks. Witches carrying plastic buckets. Tiny werewolves accompanied by exhausted parents. Somebody's front yard will contain a twelve-foot skeleton purchased at a home-improvement store, and nobody will consider this evidence of a serious problem.

My kind of people.

At least until midnight.

Then the decorations start coming down. The monsters return to storage. The skeletons go back into their boxes.

And the world starts looking normal again.

Well.

Normal for everybody else.

I still have to get dressed in the morning.


Sources: National Museum of Ireland · Historic Environment Scotland · Library of Congress · Anoka County Historical Society

Keep reading

I've Been Building Some Terrible Places

The Monster Was Better Before I Named It

← Back to the journal