Field note 033
The Village Oracle Position Has Been Eliminated
# The Village Oracle Position Has Been Eliminated
By M. J. Ellis
I think I was born into the wrong economy.
Not necessarily the wrong century. I enjoy antibiotics, air conditioning, and the ability to obtain a cheeseburger without slaughtering anything myself.
But I suspect there was a period in human history when a man with my particular collection of interests could have made a respectable living by being profoundly weird.
Picture it.
A small village, several thousand years ago.
The crops are failing. Someone's goat has developed an attitude. There's an eclipse coming, and nobody knows whether to be concerned.
The village elders gather.
"We should consult the oracle."
And somewhere at the edge of town, inside a cave that smells suspiciously of mushrooms and poor ventilation, there's me.
A man who has spent the last four days wondering whether consciousness is something the universe produces or something the universe fundamentally is.
Perfect.
They've found their guy.
A Highly Specialized Position
Now, I'm aware that my understanding of ancient spiritual employment is probably romanticized.
I'm sure actual shamans, priests, seers, and other assorted intermediaries between humanity and the supernatural had responsibilities beyond sitting around thinking about existence.
There were ceremonies. Traditions. Social obligations.
Possibly some very demanding goats.
But indulge me.
Imagine a society that encounters someone who spends an unusual amount of time thinking about things that have no obvious practical application.
Why are we here?
What happens when we die?
Is the universe conscious?
If everything comes from the same underlying reality, are individuals actually separate things?
And why does Gerald keep insisting he's God?
Instead of telling that person to stop wasting time and find something productive to do, the village makes an interesting decision.
"Clearly, this man needs to be placed somewhere dark and given access to the sacred mushrooms."
I'm not endorsing this as a medical treatment or a particularly sound hiring practice.
I'm just saying it's nice to imagine a civilization recognizing a very specific kind of uselessness and deciding to make it official.
They might even give me a ceremonial staff.
I would absolutely become insufferable about the staff.
The Modern Employment Experience
Unfortunately, I live in the twenty-first century.
And the oracle industry has undergone some restructuring.
Now, instead of receiving ceremonial robes and a modest hut near the forest, I'm expected to create an account on a website, upload my résumé, and manually enter every piece of information already contained in the résumé I just uploaded.
Then comes the assessment.
"Describe a time when you demonstrated leadership."
Well, I once developed an entire cosmological system involving consciousness, divinity, and the relationship between individuality and infinity.
"Do you have forklift experience?"
No.
"Are you willing to learn?"
Absolutely.
"Unfortunately, we have decided to move forward with other candidates."
Fair enough.
I probably shouldn't be operating heavy machinery while contemplating whether the distinction between observer and observed is ultimately an illusion.
Although, in my defense, I haven't hit anything yet.
The Problem With Being Interesting
There's an uncomfortable truth buried somewhere beneath all this nonsense.
Being interested in things doesn't necessarily make you useful.
At least not in the way people generally mean when they're talking about employment.
A man who can repair a roof possesses an immediately recognizable skill.
The roof leaks. He fixes it. Everyone understands the transaction.
A man who spends six hours exploring whether God might experience reality through individual consciousness presents a considerably more difficult business proposition.
What exactly are we purchasing here?
Can it be delivered by Friday?
Does it come with a warranty?
And I understand the problem.
Society needs people who fix roofs.
It needs people who grow food, repair machinery, transport goods, and keep the plumbing functioning.
I've never once been rescued from a backed-up toilet by a particularly compelling interpretation of the nature of reality.
But I wonder whether we've become so accustomed to measuring usefulness through immediate economic output that we've forgotten how many things we value began as someone's apparently impractical curiosity.
Art.
Music.
Philosophy.
Stories.
Scientific questions that initially seemed ridiculous.
Someone, somewhere, had to spend time thinking about something that wasn't obviously going to pay the electric bill.
Of course, that doesn't mean every strange idea is valuable.
I've had enough of them to know better.
Some ideas deserve serious consideration.
Others deserve to be written down, laughed at, and quietly escorted from the premises.
The trick is figuring out which is which.
Unfortunately, that's often difficult to determine before someone has spent an unreasonable amount of time exploring them.
Even the Oracle Had Bills
There's another problem with my ancient career fantasy.
I suspect the village oracle wasn't simply allowed to exist indefinitely without contributing anything.
Someone had to feed him.
Someone had to maintain his cave.
Someone probably had to explain to the elders why he'd spent an entire afternoon staring at a beetle instead of predicting the harvest.
And eventually somebody would ask a perfectly reasonable question.
"That's fascinating, Oracle. But is it going to rain?"
I would probably respond with a lengthy explanation of how rain is the universe participating in its own transformation.
And then they'd replace me with a man who could look at clouds.
Which, frankly, would be the correct business decision.
But perhaps the point isn't that society should support every person who enjoys staring into the philosophical abyss.
Perhaps it's that we've created an economy where certain forms of curiosity have difficulty finding a place, even when they eventually produce things people genuinely value.
A song doesn't feed anybody.
Neither does a novel.
Neither does a painting of an imaginary insect with an elaborate fictional reproductive cycle.
At least not directly.
But people keep making them.
And other people keep wanting them.
There's something interesting about that.
The Cave Has Been Privatized
Here's the part that really bothers me.
We haven't actually stopped seeking oracles.
We just changed where we find them.
We listen to philosophers, writers, scientists, artists, comedians, podcasters, and increasingly, artificial intelligence.
We ask them about existence, morality, happiness, identity, death, and what the hell we're supposed to be doing with our lives.
We still want someone to help us make sense of the strange situation we've found ourselves in.
We've even invented machines that will sit patiently and discuss the nature of consciousness with us at three in the morning.
Which is remarkable.
And slightly insulting.
I finally find a field that suits me, and humanity invents a machine that can do it without requiring food, sleep, or health insurance.
At least the ancient oracle had some job security.
Probably.
Until the goat incident.
Still, I find myself wondering whether the role ever really disappeared.
Maybe the village oracle became the philosopher.
The philosopher became the writer.
The writer became the guy sitting at his computer, turning an afternoon's existential crisis into something other people might enjoy reading.
The cave became a spare bedroom.
The sacred visions became speculative essays.
The ceremonial staff became a keyboard.
And the mushrooms became coffee.
An admittedly disappointing substitution.
But perhaps the underlying impulse never changed.
Some people look at the world and immediately wonder how to make it work.
Other people look at the world and wonder what it means that anything works at all.
We need both.
And sometimes, if we're fortunate, the second group manages to make something useful for the first.
A story.
An idea.
A joke that makes an otherwise miserable afternoon a little more tolerable.
Maybe that isn't nothing.
Maybe it was never nothing.
I don't particularly want to live in the ancient world. I enjoy having teeth, and I suspect I'd miss indoor plumbing within the first fifteen minutes.
I would, however, appreciate a society that had a slightly better answer for what to do with people whose natural inclination is to investigate the mysteries of existence.
Because at the moment, my qualifications appear to be rather specialized.
Position sought: Village Oracle.
Experience: Extensive.
Education: Largely self-inflicted.
Special skills: Existential inquiry, creative speculation, and the ability to turn an ordinary conversation into a theological problem.
Preferred working environment: Cave. Remote acceptable.
Salary requirements: Negotiable.
Unfortunately, I've checked the local housing market.
The cave is $1,400 a month.
And apparently, they want proof of income.
Keep reading
Every Hobby Eventually Requires a Suspiciously Specific Tool