Field note 002
A Joke Can Get Somewhere an Argument Can’t
Tell somebody you’d like to discuss their assumptions about God, and watch how quickly they remember an appointment.
Tell them God’s name is Gerald, and they might ask a question.
Probably “What?”
But it’s a start.
I like humor because it gives us a way into subjects we’ve already learned to defend ourselves against. Death. Religion. The possibility that we’re wrong about something important.
Most of us have familiar positions on these things. We know which arguments annoy us. Sometimes we can hear the first few words of a sentence and start assembling our response before the person finishes.
A joke can interrupt that little routine.
For a moment, you’re busy laughing.
Then you notice what you laughed at.
There’s something wonderfully awkward about a joke that leaves a question behind. You enjoyed it. Now it’s sitting there, making itself comfortable, and you can’t quite send it away without thinking about it.
That interests me as a writer.
In God’s Name Is Gerald, a grieving man has enormous questions. Putting him beside someone named Gerald creates room for a conversation that can be funny, frustrating, and painful—sometimes within a few sentences.
Grief doesn’t make people stop being ridiculous. Neither does love. You can be in the middle of something that changes your life and still notice somebody’s shoes.
Sometimes that small, stupid detail is what lets you stay in the room.
Of course, getting a laugh doesn’t make an argument true. A clever joke can be unfair. It can make somebody look foolish while quietly avoiding their actual point.
I want to watch for that in my own writing. If an idea falls apart as soon as the laughter stops, it needs more work.
But when humor helps us look at something we usually flinch away from, I think it’s doing something valuable.
You don’t have to solve death to laugh in its general direction.
You might even find that, afterward, you can talk about it for a minute.
And if the conversation gets too uncomfortable, we can discuss Gerald’s shoes.
Read next
Explore a book
For a stranger conversation about grief, God, and being alive, read a sample of God’s Name Is Gerald.
What did this bring up for you?
A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.
Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.