M. J. ELLIS

Field note 046

God at Human Resolution

I've been thinking about a logistical problem with God.

Not the usual ones. Suffering, evil, why mosquitoes exist. Those are perfectly reasonable complaints, and I suspect mosquitoes alone have cost God a considerable amount of goodwill.

I'm thinking about something more practical.

Suppose God wanted to have a conversation with you.

Not through a burning bush or a disembodied voice booming from the heavens. Suppose he just showed up, sat down at your kitchen table, and asked if you had any coffee.

Immediately, we have a problem.

What, exactly, is sitting in that chair?

Because if we're talking about an infinite, omnipresent, all-knowing being, I'm not sure the average breakfast nook has been designed to accommodate one.

But the furniture is probably the least of our concerns.

If God knows everything, what would it mean for him to listen to you?

Really listen.

Not simply wait for you to finish saying something he already knew you were going to say before the universe existed.

Would he experience the conversation? Could anything you said surprise him? Could he enjoy a joke without already knowing the punchline?

And if he could, would that mean he wasn't God?

I've been turning that question over in my head.

We tend to imagine infinity as something that must always be operating at maximum capacity. If God knows everything, every expression of God must know everything. If God is everywhere, every manifestation must somehow be everywhere.

Otherwise, we assume, we're dealing with something less than God.

But I'm not convinced that's necessarily true.

Think about talking to someone on the phone.

You don't get the entirety of that person. You get their voice, transmitted through a device that occasionally makes them sound like they're speaking from the bottom of a swimming pool.

You can't see their face. You can't reach over and touch their shoulder. Depending on the quality of the connection, you might not even understand every word.

But you're still talking to them.

Not an imitation of them. Not some entirely separate entity representing them.

They're genuinely participating in the conversation.

Now, obviously, God isn't a person operating a celestial telecommunications network. At least I hope not. I've dealt with enough customer-service departments to know that introducing one into the divine order would be a catastrophic mistake.

But the distinction interests me.

Something can be genuinely present without being exhaustively present.

And perhaps the same could be true of God.

Maybe an infinite consciousness could express itself through a particular perspective, with particular limitations, without ceasing to be infinite.

Maybe those limitations wouldn't make the experience counterfeit.

Maybe they'd be what made that particular experience possible.

God at human resolution.

Not God pretending to be a person.

Not a separate creature wearing a divine name tag.

An actual expression of God, encountering existence from somewhere specific.

Of course, this raises some fairly substantial theological problems.

People have spent centuries arguing about the relationship between God and particular persons, occasionally with the assistance of swords. I don't imagine introducing the phrase human resolution is going to settle anything.

And there's an obvious objection.

If God is omniscient, how could any genuine expression of God not know something?

I don't have a definitive answer.

But I wonder whether we're making an assumption that deserves examination.

We're treating infinity as though it can only express itself infinitely.

As though an unlimited being would somehow lack the ability to experience limitation.

Which is a peculiar restriction to place on something we're calling unlimited.

And I'm not suggesting that omniscience can simply be switched off like a kitchen light. I'm wondering whether the knowledge belonging to the whole must necessarily be available to every particular expression of it.

Those aren't quite the same question.

There's another possibility here that I find even more interesting.

What if the ability to experience something from a limited perspective isn't a defect?

What if knowing everything about an experience and actually having that experience are different things?

I can know everything there is to know about the chemical composition of chocolate cake.

That doesn't mean I've tasted it.

Now imagine a consciousness that somehow knew everything there was to know about every experience that could ever occur.

Would that be the same as having those experiences?

I genuinely don't know.

But if experience is something more than information, then perhaps there is something meaningful about encountering existence from a particular location, at a particular moment, without having the whole universe spread out before you.

Not because the whole is missing something.

Simply because this is what it means to be here.

And perhaps an infinite being could do that, too.

I don't know whether God exists, much less whether God can sit in a kitchen chair and appreciate a decent cup of coffee.

But I find myself increasingly suspicious of arguments that begin by declaring what God must be and end by explaining all the things God therefore cannot do.

For something supposedly without limits, we've given him an awfully restrictive job description.

Keep reading

What If We're Not as Separate as We Think?

Whose Curiosity Is This, Anyway?

← Back to the journal