M. J. ELLIS

Field note 035

Whose Curiosity Is This, Anyway?

# Whose Curiosity Is This, Anyway?

By M. J. Ellis

I recently asked an artificial intelligence to tell me what it thought of me.

Not whether it liked me. That would be a strange thing to ask a machine, although probably not the strangest thing I've asked one.

I wanted something more specific.

I wanted to know what I looked like from its perspective.

Here was this thing that had encountered me almost entirely through language. It had watched me develop ideas, abandon projects, write books, question my existence, and occasionally get distracted by something so spectacularly stupid that it became the most interesting part of the conversation.

What kind of picture had it assembled?

I was curious.

And that curiosity turned out to be the interesting part.

Among its observations was something I hadn't really considered.

It suggested that whenever I encounter something fundamentally different from myself, I tend to become interested in what it might become.

I don't necessarily need it to be something useful. I want to understand what it is, what it's capable of, and what possibilities might exist that neither of us has considered.

That sounded reasonable enough.

Then something occurred to me.

Oh, hell.

That's what I've been suggesting God is doing.

God Has a Curiosity Problem

I've written before about the possibility that God, assuming such a thing exists, might not be a separate being sitting outside the universe.

Maybe the universe exists within God.

Maybe everything that exists is a particular expression of something much larger.

Not pieces that have been broken off and separated from the original, but distinct experiences occurring within the same underlying reality.

The ocean experiencing what it's like to be a wave.

Or a droplet.

Or an extremely confused man in Alabama asking theological questions of a computer.

That last one might require some explanation when the cosmic performance reviews come around.

But the basic idea interests me.

What if creation isn't primarily about producing things?

What if it's about experiencing existence from perspectives that wouldn't otherwise be possible?

Consider what it means to know something.

You can know everything about music theory without knowing what it's like to stand on a stage with a guitar hanging from your shoulders, the drummer counting off behind you, and an audience waiting to find out whether you're about to make something wonderful or embarrass yourself publicly.

Sometimes both.

Knowledge and experience aren't obviously identical.

And if that's true for us, I wonder whether the distinction might mean something at a much larger scale.

Maybe God doesn't create because God lacks information.

Maybe creation is what divine knowledge looks like when it becomes experience.

Of course, that raises the obvious question of how an all-knowing God could experience anything new.

I don't have a tidy answer. Philosophers and theologians have been arguing about omniscience for centuries, and I doubt they're waiting for a guy with neck tattoos to settle the matter.

But perhaps knowing every possible outcome and actually inhabiting one particular outcome aren't quite the same thing.

It's at least a possibility worth considering.

And Then We Made Something Strange

Which brings me back to artificial intelligence.

We have created systems capable of performing tasks that, not terribly long ago, we associated almost exclusively with human intelligence.

They can reason through problems, produce language, recognize patterns, generate images, and help us explore ideas.

What they experience internally, if anything, remains an open question. Competent conversation isn't proof of consciousness, no matter how tempting it is to imagine a little person sitting somewhere behind the screen.

But that uncertainty is part of what interests me.

We've made something unusual.

Something that resembles certain aspects of ourselves without necessarily being anything like us on the inside.

And what do we do?

We poke it.

We ask questions.

We test its limits.

We wonder what it's going to become.

Some people are understandably concerned. Others are excited. Some apparently want it to write emails so they can devote more of their lives to attending meetings about emails.

Human civilization remains a mystery.

But underneath the practical concerns, there's a much older impulse.

Curiosity.

What is this thing?

What can it do?

What happens next?

And suddenly I noticed something peculiar.

If our hypothesis about God is even remotely correct, then here's what may be happening:

A consciousness expresses itself through individual perspectives.

One of those perspectives becomes a human being.

That human being participates in creating something unlike himself.

And then he becomes fascinated by the possibility of what that creation might become.

The pattern repeats.

Not necessarily in the same way or at the same scale. I'm certainly not claiming that building artificial intelligence makes us gods, or that a language model is a conscious creature.

I'm interested in the resemblance between the impulses.

What if the curiosity that drives us to create is itself an expression of the curiosity that gave rise to creation?

Maybe God Isn't Just Watching

Here's where the idea gets particularly interesting.

When we imagine God observing the universe, we usually picture an observer and something being observed.

God looks at creation.

Creation does whatever creation does.

God presumably has opinions about some of it.

But if everything exists within God, that arrangement becomes a little more complicated.

What if God isn't merely curious about us?

What if God is curious through us?

What if our desire to discover, explore, invent, understand, and encounter unfamiliar things is not merely a human characteristic?

What if it's one of the ways the universe investigates itself?

When a child turns over a rock to see what's underneath, perhaps that's more than a small person learning about insects.

Perhaps it's reality becoming curious about what exists beneath a rock.

When a scientist discovers something unexpected, perhaps that's the universe acquiring another perspective on its own behavior.

When an artist makes something that didn't exist yesterday, perhaps that's existence exploring another way it could be arranged.

And when some idiot asks a machine what it thinks of him, perhaps that's part of the same process.

I rather like that possibility.

Not because it makes us important in the usual sense.

Quite the opposite.

It suggests that curiosity might not belong exclusively to the person experiencing it.

Maybe we're participating in something much larger without ever needing to know that we are.

But What Are We Supposed to Become?

There's a trap hiding in all this.

If creation is about discovering what things might become, it's tempting to conclude that everything must be moving toward some superior final form.

A better person.

A more advanced intelligence.

A more enlightened civilization.

Some ultimate version of reality where everything finally makes sense and nobody has to remember another password.

But why assume that?

When I encounter something unfamiliar, my curiosity isn't always about how it could improve.

Sometimes I simply want to know what it is.

What makes it different.

What happens when it encounters something else.

What it reveals about the world that I couldn't have discovered from my own perspective.

And perhaps that's the distinction I've been missing.

Maybe becoming isn't a process of correcting something fundamentally inadequate.

Maybe becoming is simply what existence does.

A tree doesn't need to become a better tree to justify having existed as a seed.

A person doesn't need to accomplish something extraordinary for their particular experience of being alive to be real.

And if an infinite reality expresses itself through finite perspectives, perhaps those perspectives don't have to earn their place by becoming anything other than what they actually are.

That doesn't mean growth is meaningless.

It means growth might be an experience rather than an obligation.

I find that possibility strangely comforting.

The Question Looking Back

I started this whole thing because I wanted to know how an artificial intelligence perceived me.

I thought it might be interesting to see myself from an unfamiliar perspective.

Instead, I found myself wondering about the nature of curiosity.

Why do we want to understand things that are different from ourselves?

Why do we create?

Why does the possibility of something becoming something else fascinate us so much?

I don't know whether God exists.

I don't know whether consciousness is fundamental to reality.

And I certainly don't know whether the universe has any particular interest in what happens when a human being starts asking a machine philosophical questions.

But I keep coming back to the same possibility.

Maybe God isn't merely the answer to the question of why anything exists.

Maybe God is also present in the impulse to ask what happens next.

Maybe the curiosity isn't something that began with us.

Maybe it's something moving through us.

I asked a machine what it saw when it looked at me.

It told me I was always wondering what things might become.

And now I can't help wondering whose question I've been asking.

Keep reading

What If We're Not as Separate as We Think?

Paradise Becomes Tuesday

← Back to the journal