M. J. ELLIS

Field note 017

Paradise Becomes Tuesday

By M. J. Ellis

I've been wondering about something.

If everyone in the universe were happy all the time, would happiness even exist?

Or would it simply become normal?

Imagine a world without sadness, disappointment, grief, anxiety, or suffering. Everyone is perfectly happy. All day. Every day. Forever.

Sounds wonderful.

For about five minutes.

Then I start wondering whether anyone living in that world would even know they were happy.

How could they?

They've never experienced anything else.

They wouldn't wake up in the morning thinking, "Man, it's great to be happy."

They'd just wake up.

And that got me thinking about paradise.

We're Already Living in Somebody Else's Paradise

Consider how an ordinary person lives today compared to someone living a thousand years ago.

We have climate control, refrigeration, antibiotics, modern medicine, nearly unlimited entertainment, and access to more information than the greatest libraries of the ancient world could have contained.

A medieval king could command armies, possess unimaginable wealth, and rule over thousands of people.

But if he had a toothache, things could get ugly.

Meanwhile, I can sit in an air-conditioned house, eat food that traveled halfway around the planet, and watch a little rectangle in my hand show me what the surface of Mars looks like.

And what do I do when that rectangle takes three seconds to load something?

I become furious.

Three seconds.

Apparently, instantaneous access to the accumulated knowledge of human civilization isn't good enough anymore.

I want it faster.

And I'm hardly unusual.

We've inherited conveniences that previous generations could scarcely have imagined, and somehow we've managed to make them ordinary.

Yesterday's miracle becomes today's minimum expectation.

Paradise becomes Tuesday.

Maybe Happiness Needs an Opposite

There's an idea in Hermetic philosophy, particularly as presented in The Kybalion, called the Principle of Polarity.

The basic suggestion is that things we consider opposites may actually be different degrees of the same underlying thing.

Hot and cold. Light and darkness. Love and hate.

I've been wondering whether happiness and unhappiness work similarly.

Perhaps we only recognize happiness because we've experienced its absence.

A cold drink is wonderful when you're hot.

Rest feels incredible when you're exhausted.

A peaceful afternoon can feel almost sacred after a difficult week.

But if you're never hot, never tired, and never troubled, do those experiences retain the same significance?

There's a psychological phenomenon called hedonic adaptation. Essentially, human beings tend to get used to improvements in their circumstances.

Something wonderful happens. We're thrilled.

Then time passes.

The wonderful thing becomes part of ordinary life, and we start looking for the next wonderful thing.

It's almost as though we're less interested in occupying a happy state than in moving toward one.

Which raises an uncomfortable possibility.

Maybe the paradise we imagine would eventually become just another ordinary place to live.

With excellent weather, presumably.

And someone complaining about it.

But Does Ordinary Mean Meaningless?

Here's where I have to challenge my own thinking.

Just because something no longer feels extraordinary doesn't mean it has lost its value.

Clean drinking water doesn't become worthless because I no longer celebrate it every morning.

And happiness might work the same way.

Someone could conceivably experience a pleasant, peaceful existence forever, even if they never stopped to identify it as happiness.

After all, a thing doesn't cease to exist just because we stop noticing it.

So perhaps the question isn't whether happiness would exist in paradise.

Perhaps the question is whether happiness alone would make paradise worth experiencing.

Because when I really think about it, I'm not sure I'd choose an eternity of guaranteed happiness.

I think I'd choose something else.

I Think I'd Rather Be Surprised

Suppose someone offered me two universes.

In the first, I'm guaranteed to be happy forever.

Nothing can hurt me. Nothing can disappoint me. Every experience is pleasant.

In the second, nothing is guaranteed.

There's joy and grief, triumph and failure, love and loss. There are things I don't understand and perhaps never will. There are discoveries I couldn't possibly anticipate.

And yes, there's the possibility of suffering.

I'd choose the second.

Not because I enjoy suffering. I've had enough of that to know better.

And certainly not because I believe people need to suffer to deserve happiness.

I'd happily eliminate an enormous amount of unnecessary suffering from existence if somebody handed me the appropriate cosmic paperwork.

But I don't think happiness is the only thing that makes being alive worthwhile.

There's wonder.

There's curiosity.

There's the excitement of discovering that something you thought you understood is far stranger than you imagined.

There's the peculiar pleasure of being wrong about something and realizing that the truth is more interesting than your original belief.

And there are experiences that aren't necessarily happy or unhappy.

They're simply profound.

I don't know that I'd want to trade those possibilities for perpetual contentment.

What If We've Got Paradise Backward?

Maybe our mistake is imagining paradise as a place where everything has already been resolved.

Every question answered.

Every desire satisfied.

Every problem eliminated.

Nothing left to fear, nothing left to overcome, nothing left to discover.

Just happiness.

Forever.

But what if paradise isn't supposed to be the end of the search?

What if it's a place where the search never has to end?

Imagine an existence where curiosity is inexhaustible. Where every discovery opens another door. Where you can experience wonder without requiring tragedy to make it meaningful.

Perhaps different kinds of happiness could provide all the contrast we need.

The quiet happiness of peace.

The explosive happiness of discovery.

The happiness of connection, creation, understanding, and surprise.

Maybe we don't need pain to appreciate joy.

Maybe we just need the possibility of experiencing something different.

And if that's true, perhaps the thing I should fear isn't unhappiness.

Perhaps it's stagnation.

I don't know.

There are plenty of people who would reasonably choose the first universe. An existence free from suffering is nothing to dismiss, particularly for someone who has suffered more than enough.

But I keep returning to the same thought.

I don't want to reach a point where existence has nothing left to show me.

I don't want every mystery solved or every possibility exhausted.

I don't want to arrive at the end of eternity only to discover that there's nothing left to wonder about.

Maybe paradise isn't a place where we're finally happy forever.

Maybe paradise is a place where forever still isn't enough time to see everything.

Read next

Explore a book

For a closer look at perception and the assumptions behind experience, read a sample of The Book You Are Not Supposed to Finish.

What did this bring up for you?

A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.

Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.
Back to the journal