Field note 047
I Have a Bigfoot Story
I have a Bigfoot story.
Well, I had a Bigfoot story.
For more than thirty years, my family possessed something considerably more convincing than a blurry photograph of a hairy man walking through the woods.
We had eyewitnesses.
My Uncle Jim and my Uncle Bart, also known as Dean.
Now, you need to understand something about these two men. When I was a little boy, they were among the toughest human beings I knew. They weren't easily frightened, and they certainly weren't the sort of men who would admit to being frightened.
Which is why the story was so compelling.
The two of them had gone camping. Sometime during the night, something began hurling rocks at their tents. Whatever it was apparently decided that throwing rocks wasn't sufficient entertainment and began chasing them.
They fled.
They came home in the middle of the night.
Without their tents.
Now, I don't know what your particular standards of evidence are, but as a little boy, two grown men abandoning perfectly good camping equipment because something terrifying was pursuing them through the woods seemed pretty conclusive.
They never actually said it was Bigfoot.
They didn't have to.
What else could it have been?
And these weren't strangers on television. These were my uncles. People we knew. People we trusted. People who, as far as we were concerned, would sooner fight a monster than admit one had frightened them.
So we believed them.
And we told people.
For decades.
Over thirty years, this story circulated through our family. It was repeated at gatherings, shared with friends, and offered as evidence whenever the subject of Bigfoot came up.
We weren't speculating. We knew people who had encountered something.
We had a family connection to the mysterious.
Other people had grainy photographs and questionable footprints.
We had Uncle Jim.
And I suppose that's what made it so convincing. It wasn't really about Bigfoot. It was about knowing the people who told the story. We weren't evaluating evidence. We were evaluating character.
And we had already decided these men were credible.
Which brings me to a family dinner a few weeks ago.
The Bigfoot story came up.
Naturally.
It was practically a family heirloom at this point.
Uncle Bart had passed away some time ago, but Jim was there.
And apparently Jim decided that thirty-something years was a respectable amount of time to let a joke run.
"Oh, we made that up," he said. "I guess since Bart's not here, I'll let you in on it."
Hehehe.
I'm sorry.
What?
His own brothers were sitting there looking as shocked as the rest of us.
Apparently, this had been a two-man operation from the beginning. The rest of the family had simply been recruited into what I can only describe as a decades-long public relations campaign for a creature that may or may not exist.
And I'll admit, I was a little pissed.
Not because I was particularly attached to Bigfoot.
But because I'd been telling people this story for over thirty years.
We all had.
We had vouched for these men. We had defended their credibility. We had confidently repeated their account to people who had absolutely no reason to believe us, and probably shouldn't have.
There is a particular kind of humiliation in discovering that you've been sincerely full of shit for most of your life.
And the man responsible is sitting across from you giggling.
Sir.
There are people walking around this planet who believe in Bigfoot specifically because of YOU.
You don't get to casually dismantle an entire family's understanding of North American wildlife between bites of dinner.
There should be some kind of formal process for this.
A hearing, perhaps.
At the very least, I feel we're entitled to a written retraction.
But no.
Hehehe.
And here's the thing that has stuck with me.
For thirty years, I wasn't lying when I told that story.
Neither was anyone else in my family.
We genuinely believed it.
We knew our sources. We trusted their character. We had no reason to suspect otherwise.
I was a child when I first heard it. Eventually, I became an adult who repeated it. Somewhere along the way, a story I'd been told became something I knew.
I never noticed the transition.
And every time we repeated it, the story became just a little more established. Another person heard it from someone who sincerely believed it. Another person could say they knew a family who had experienced something strange.
The story acquired credibility simply by surviving.
It didn't become any more true.
It just got older.
And at its center were two men who knew the entire thing was nonsense.
I find that fascinating, actually.
Because it makes me wonder how many things I believe today have a similar history. Things I've never personally investigated because somebody I trusted had already done the believing for me.
Not necessarily some grand deception. Not an elaborate conspiracy.
Just somebody making something up, somebody else believing them, and enough time passing that nobody thinks to ask anymore.
I suppose that's how folklore works.
It's also possible that my uncle is simply an asshole.
Those explanations aren't mutually exclusive.
But I have to give Jim and Dean credit for something.
They managed to pull off a practical joke that lasted more than three decades, survived the death of one of its architects, and convinced an entire extended family that a giant hairy creature was wandering around the woods throwing rocks at campers.
That's extraordinary.
And I still have a Bigfoot story.
It's just that Bigfoot isn't the most unbelievable part anymore.
Probably Nothing.