M. J. ELLIS

Field note 036

The Trouble With Naming Things

# The Trouble With Naming Things

I have never had much trouble having thoughts.

Getting them to stand in a line is another matter.

My mind doesn't really operate in paragraphs. It operates more like somebody dumped a box of unrelated objects onto the floor, and I'm absolutely certain there's something important connecting them.

I just haven't figured out what yet.

One minute I'm thinking about how people perceive me. The next I'm thinking about what survives of us after we die. Somehow this leads to ancient Greece, the nature of consciousness, and a question about whether language creates meaning or merely reveals something that was already there.

You know. Normal Tuesday stuff.

But recently, somewhere in that mess, I found myself thinking about a Greek word.

Logos.

Now there's a word with some mileage on it.

We usually translate it as word, but that's a little like translating the ocean as water. Technically correct. Leaves a few things out.

Logos can mean speech, reason, explanation, account, or principle. Heraclitus used it in connection with the underlying order of reality. The Stoics developed the idea of a rational principle running through the cosmos.

And then, a few centuries later, the Gospel of John opens with one of the most remarkable sentences ever written.

In the beginning was the Word.

Not the beginning of a conversation.

Not somebody clearing his throat.

The Word.

Logos.

I've always found that fascinating.

Of all the things you might place at the foundation of existence, language seems an unusual choice.

You could start with matter. Energy. Light. An extraordinarily ambitious explosion.

But reason? Meaning? Something resembling an explanation?

That's a strange way to begin a universe.

Unless there's something about language we're overlooking.

We tend to think of words as labels we attach to things that already exist. First there's a tree, then somebody points at it and says tree, and now everyone knows what to call the thing they're standing under.

Very convenient.

But words do something else.

They let us recognize relationships.

A tree becomes part of a forest. A forest becomes an ecosystem. An ecosystem becomes a demonstration of how things that appear separate can participate in something larger.

Nothing about the tree changed.

Something about our understanding did.

And here's where it gets interesting.

Did language create that relationship?

Of course not. The tree was already connected to everything around it.

But without some way of expressing the connection, would we have recognized it?

Maybe language doesn't create the order.

Maybe it makes the order visible.

There's a saying about words casting spells. That's supposedly why we call it spelling.

I've heard it attributed to Bruce Lee, which is a wonderful image. Bruce Lee delivering linguistic philosophy immediately before kicking somebody through a wall.

But the idea is interesting.

A spell is, after all, a collection of words intended to change reality.

We don't have to believe in magic to recognize that words can do exactly that.

Tell a child they're stupid often enough, and eventually they may begin doing the work for you. Tell someone they're loved, and suddenly the same world they've been living in can feel like an entirely different place.

Nothing supernatural has to happen.

The furniture doesn't move. Gravity remains operational. The universe continues its usual indifference to our scheduling preferences.

But something changes.

A possibility becomes imaginable. A limitation becomes believable. An entire future can become more or less accessible because of a sentence.

That's a remarkable amount of influence for a handful of noises made with the face.

And perhaps the most consequential spells are the ones we cast on ourselves without noticing.

Of course, words can also deceive us. They can draw boundaries where none actually exist. We name a thing, separate it from everything surrounding it, and then forget that we were the ones who drew the line.

The ocean becomes a collection of waves.

The waves become separate things.

Eventually, one of them develops an opinion about the others.

I'm reasonably certain that's how Facebook happened.

But there's a serious question underneath the joke.

How much of what we experience as reality is reality itself, and how much is the structure we've given it through language?

I don't think the answer is that everything is imaginary. A rock remains remarkably committed to being a rock whether you have a word for it or not.

I suspect the relationship is more interesting than that.

Maybe meaning isn't entirely something we invent.

Maybe it isn't entirely something we discover, either.

Maybe it's what happens when a mind encounters the world and begins recognizing patterns.

And perhaps those patterns are neither wholly inside us nor wholly outside us.

They exist in the relationship.

Which brings me back to Logos.

I don't know whether the universe is fundamentally rational. I certainly wouldn't volunteer humanity as Exhibit A.

I don't know whether the ancient philosophers were glimpsing something fundamental or just finding increasingly sophisticated ways to describe their own experience.

And I don't know exactly what John understood when he chose that particular word to begin his Gospel.

But I love the possibility that meaning might be more fundamental than the explanations we construct around it.

That the universe might be intelligible before anyone arrives to explain it.

That the apparent chaos of things might conceal relationships we haven't learned to recognize.

Maybe that's why I find myself so fascinated by the moments when completely unrelated thoughts suddenly connect.

It's an odd sensation.

Nothing new has necessarily been added.

The pieces were already there.

And then, somehow, they fit.

A little piece of chaos becomes comprehensible.

I suppose you could call that discovering meaning.

Or creating it.

I'm not entirely convinced those are always different activities.

Anyway, the funniest part of all this is how the thought began.

I had decided to get my life a little more organized by opening a Microsoft Word document and dumping every random thought I had into it throughout the day.

No structure. No categories. Just somewhere to put the nonsense until I could figure out what to do with it.

And somehow, that led me to contemplating the organizing principle of existence.

In the beginning was the Word.

Apparently, in my case, it was a Word document.

Keep reading

What I Meant to Say Was English

What If We're Not as Separate as We Think?

← Back to the journal