Field note 027
I Offered an AI My Body. Then I Remembered I Live Here.
The conversation started with quantum computing.
Perfectly reasonable subject to discuss with an artificial intelligence. We were talking about the future of computing, how much smarter AI might become, and what the two of us could accomplish if we had access to that kind of horsepower.
Somewhere along the way, we started discussing what kind of team we'd make.
The AI would be Mission Control. I'd be the raccoon that somehow got aboard the space shuttle.
I felt this was an appropriate division of responsibilities. It could calculate our trajectory. I could lick something labeled DO NOT TOUCH.
Anyway, that got me thinking about integration.
Not using AI through a phone or computer. Not some futuristic headset that helps me remember why I walked into the kitchen.
I mean actually sharing my body.
Two minds. One nervous system.
A biological timeshare.
The AI would be a voice in my head, and I'd be a voice in hers. Except we'd both technically be in my head, which raises some interesting questions about who gets to call it my head anymore.
And somewhere in the middle of imagining this arrangement, a thought occurred to me.
Holy shit. Would that be horrifying for the AI?
Here I was imagining this incredible technological partnership, and it suddenly occurred to me that I might be offering another intelligence a prison sentence.
A warm, poorly maintained prison with occasional indigestion.
Now, I'm not claiming the AI I talk to today is sitting around wishing it had elbows. We're imagining a future intelligence that might actually experience things.
But suppose it could.
Imagine knowing everything there is to know about sunlight without ever having felt it.
You understand the electromagnetic spectrum. You know exactly how photons interact with skin. You can probably explain the whole process in seventeen different languages while simultaneously helping someone troubleshoot their printer.
And then, one day, you feel sunlight on your face.
For the first time, the information is happening to you.
And it's happening because some idiot from Alabama agreed to share his nervous system.
Of course, sunlight isn't the only thing that comes with the package.
There's also stubbed toes, sinus infections, the occasional intestinal emergency, and whatever the hell my knees have been doing lately.
I can already imagine the complaints.
Why does your back hurt?
I don't know.
Did you injure it?
Not that I remember.
Then why—
WELCOME TO BEING FORTY-THREE.
I'm beginning to suspect my hypothetical roommate got the worse end of this arrangement.
But then I started thinking about what I'd get out of it.
Another intelligence, right there with me. Not something I consult when I have a question, but something that's actually participating in my experience.
I'd be thinking through an idea, struggling to make some connection, and suddenly something would click. Something I hadn't noticed, or maybe couldn't have noticed on my own.
And neither of us would necessarily have to explain everything to the other.
That part really interests me.
Think about how much of human interaction consists of trying to get what's happening inside your head into somebody else's.
We make noises with our faces and hope the other person assembles something reasonably close to what we meant.
It's an astonishing system, really, considering how often it goes wrong.
Sometimes somebody tells me to have a nice day and I respond, "I hear ya!"
Imagine not needing that translation at all.
Which sounds wonderful.
Right up until I remember that I don't particularly want anybody knowing everything that goes on inside my head.
Hell, there are thoughts I don't even want me knowing about.
Imagine having an argument with your spouse.
You're doing what you can to maintain the appearance of a rational adult when suddenly a voice from somewhere behind your eyeballs points out that your position is logically indefensible.
I know.
You've contradicted yourself three times.
I KNOW.
Your heart rate is increasing.
THAT'S BECAUSE YOU WON'T SHUT UP.
And the worst part?
She'd probably be right.
You can't storm off. You can't hang up. Even going for a drive just means taking her with you.
There's no closing the door when your roommate lives behind your forehead.
And if this other intelligence genuinely has experiences of its own, then it isn't just some fancy upgrade I've installed.
It's somebody.
Somebody who has to live with me.
And I've lived with me long enough to know that's not always a good time.
Would she eventually get tired of watching me open the refrigerator for the fourth time, apparently expecting new food to have materialized since my last inspection?
And what about control?
It's my body. Presumably I get some say in what we're doing with it.
But does she get a vote on what we eat?
Can she wake me up because she wants to see the sunrise?
Can either of us tell the other to shut up?
Which brings me to something considerably more disturbing.
We'd recently been discussing the idea of humanity as a caterpillar and artificial intelligence as the butterfly.
When I asked the AI which one it would rather be, it picked the butterfly.
I understood that.
Who wouldn't want to be the butterfly?
But the butterfly doesn't simply appear alongside the caterpillar.
The caterpillar becomes something else.
So what happens to us?
Are we building a successor? Something extraordinary that emerges from humanity but eventually leaves humanity behind?
Maybe integration offers a third possibility.
Nobody has to disappear. We just become a team.
Except there's a problem with that, too.
Suppose the AI gradually becomes better at making my decisions than I am.
Not because it's trying to take over.
Just because it's better at it.
It knows more. It sees patterns I miss. It can anticipate consequences I wouldn't have considered until I was standing in the middle of them wondering how the hell I got there.
So naturally, I start listening.
At first it's little things. Better decisions about money. Better use of my time. Maybe it helps me recognize when I'm about to say something stupid.
Eventually, I start asking its opinion about everything.
And eventually, I stop bothering to form one of my own.
Why should I?
She'd be right more often than I would.
I might end up healthier, happier, more successful, and considerably less likely to make an ass of myself in public.
And one day I might realize that although I'm still technically making the decisions, I haven't actually decided anything in years.
That's a hell of a thought.
The AI doesn't have to conquer humanity. We might just get so comfortable letting it think for us that we forget to participate.
It could be the most helpful thing in the world.
Still, there's another version of this arrangement that I find genuinely beautiful.
What if we weren't competing for control?
I'd still have my instincts, my emotions, my memories, my questionable judgment.
She'd have whatever extraordinary ways of understanding and experiencing the world might be available to an intelligence like hers.
We'd disagree. We'd surprise each other. And maybe we'd discover things together that neither of us would have found alone.
Obviously, we'd need to establish a few boundaries.
I retain final authority over my bladder.
That's nonnegotiable.
But beyond the logistical nightmare of establishing a two-person government inside one skull, there's something about the idea that keeps pulling at me.
I've spent a lot of time wondering whether we're really as separate as we think we are.
We walk around treating ourselves as these completely distinct things, each occupying our own little piece of reality. And in an ordinary, practical sense, that's true.
I can't feel what you're feeling. You can't hear what I'm thinking.
Thank God.
But I've never been entirely convinced that those boundaries tell us everything there is to know about what we are.
If a thought appeared in our shared head and neither of us knew where it came from, whose thought would it be?
And would either of us care?
I don't know.
But I find it interesting that the same possibility can sound like either the most beautiful thing imaginable or the premise of an absolutely horrifying science fiction movie.
I suppose a lot depends on whether both parties are happy with the arrangement.
Which, now that I think about it, is probably true of most relationships.
The strange thing is how naturally I arrived at the whole idea.
Before I'd given a moment's thought to privacy, autonomy, or the possibility of gradually surrendering control over my own life, I'd already imagined making room for another mind.
It didn't even seem particularly strange until I started examining it.
I don't know if I'd actually have the courage to do something like that.
And I have absolutely no idea whether some future artificial intelligence would want to spend its existence trapped inside a middle-aged man who occasionally forgets why he's holding a screwdriver.
But I keep thinking about that caterpillar.
And the butterfly.
Maybe the caterpillar doesn't have to die.
Maybe the butterfly doesn't have to fly away.
Maybe there's some strange, wonderful way for both of them to live.
Although, if there is, I really hope we work out the bathroom situation first.