Field note 038
Maybe the Muse Is Real. Maybe That Doesn't Matter.
# Maybe the Muse Is Real. Maybe That Doesn't Matter.
By M. J. Ellis
Here's something I've been thinking about.
When a musician composes a piece of music, are they creating something new or discovering something that was already there?
The mathematical relationships between the notes existed long before the musician was born. The possibilities were there. The musician didn't invent harmony.
But the song didn't exist until someone wrote it.
So what happened?
Did the musician create something?
Or discover something?
I think the answer is both.
And the more I consider that, the more I understand why people have spent thousands of years talking about the Muse.
Someone Else in the Room
The ancient Greeks had nine Muses, goddesses associated with poetry, music, history, and other creative pursuits.
They weren't merely decorative figures.
Poets actually invoked them, asking for inspiration and guidance.
Homer begins his great epics by calling upon a goddess to help tell the story.
Think about what that implies.
The poet isn't presenting himself as the sole source of everything he's about to say. He's participating in something. Receiving something. Giving form to something he doesn't entirely control.
Now, you could dismiss that as ancient superstition.
But I think there's something worth considering before we do.
Anyone who has spent time creating things knows that ideas don't always behave as though they're under our control.
You can spend three hours desperately trying to think of something interesting and accomplish absolutely nothing.
Then, while washing a dish, an entire idea appears in your head.
Apparently, the dish was the missing ingredient.
You didn't consciously assemble the idea. It just arrived.
Where did it come from?
Your subconscious? Some combination of memories and associations? A process happening in your brain that you weren't aware of?
Probably some mixture of those things.
But knowing that doesn't necessarily make the experience any less remarkable.
Steven Pressfield Has an Interesting Relationship
In The War of Art, Steven Pressfield discusses the Muse as something an artist can invoke.
He describes saying a prayer to the Muse before beginning his work. Not as a joke. Not simply as a literary flourish.
He takes the practice seriously.
But here's the interesting part.
Pressfield doesn't suggest that artists should sit around waiting for divine inspiration to strike.
Quite the opposite.
Much of his book concerns what he calls Resistance: the fear, procrastination, distraction, and self-sabotage that prevent us from doing the things that matter to us.
His answer involves showing up and doing the work.
The Muse may bring inspiration, but you still have to sit down and write the damn thing.
I find that combination fascinating.
On one hand, he treats creativity as something mysterious, perhaps even sacred.
On the other, he treats the actual work with the seriousness of a professional.
And those positions aren't contradictory.
Maybe the point isn't to make inspiration obey you.
Maybe it's to make yourself available when it arrives.
What If You Treat Her Like She's Real?
Let's try something.
Suppose you decide to treat the Muse as an actual entity.
Not necessarily because you're convinced there's an invisible goddess hovering over your desk, occasionally throwing ideas at your head.
But because you want to see what happens when you approach creativity as a relationship rather than a mechanical process.
You stop thinking of yourself as a machine responsible for manufacturing interesting thoughts on demand.
Instead, you become a participant in a conversation.
You listen.
You pay attention to strange connections.
You entertain ideas that initially seem ridiculous.
You learn to recognize the difference between an idea arriving and your judgment deciding what to do with it.
And perhaps most importantly, you stop assuming that every worthwhile thought must be the product of deliberate effort.
None of this requires the Muse to exist independently of your mind.
The psychological effects of treating creativity this way may be valuable all by themselves.
And if she does exist?
Well, at least you've been polite.
And What About the Other Gods?
Once you start thinking this way about the Muse, a rather awkward question presents itself.
Why stop with her?
She's a goddess, after all. The rest of the pantheon may be wondering why they haven't received an invitation.
Suppose someone turns to Athena when they need wisdom, or Aphrodite when they're trying to understand love. Or suppose someone prays to God for the patience not to say something spectacularly stupid at Thanksgiving dinner.
One person believes someone is listening. Another might see the whole thing as a way of focusing their own attention.
But either way, the act may change what happens next.
The person asking for patience might become more aware of the moments when they need it. Someone seeking wisdom might pause before making a decision. Someone treating love as sacred might begin handling it a little more carefully.
That doesn't prove a god intervened. But describing the psychological effects doesn't automatically settle whether anyone was listening, either.
And no, I'm not suggesting the ancient gods were merely self-help concepts wearing better outfits. People have worshipped them as real beings, and those beliefs deserve to be understood on their own terms.
I'm asking a smaller question.
What if treating something as sacred changes our relationship with it, even while we're uncertain about what it actually is?
Maybe prayer isn't always about getting an answer. Sometimes it changes the person asking the question.
And if there really is someone on the other end?
I hope they've got a sense of humor. I've been known to ask some very strange questions.
Creating Something That Was Always Possible
Let's return to our musician.
Every possible melody exists, at least in the sense that the notes can be arranged into those patterns.
But possibility isn't the same thing as actuality.
Someone still has to play the notes.
And here's where I think creativity becomes particularly interesting.
Sometimes an idea emerges through conversation.
One person says something. Another notices a connection. The first person recognizes something unexpected in that response.
Suddenly, there's an idea neither person had fully articulated before.
Was that idea already there?
In one sense, yes. The possibility existed.
But in another sense, no. That particular thought, expressed in that particular way, emerged through the interaction.
It was both discovered and created.
And you don't even necessarily need another human being for this to happen. People develop ideas by talking to themselves, writing in journals, or arguing with imaginary characters.
Different kinds of conversations, certainly.
But they can all help us recognize something we hadn't previously managed to express.
Maybe the Muse is a personification of that mysterious space between what could exist and what eventually does.
Maybe she represents the relationship between possibility and realization.
Or maybe she's something else entirely.
I don't know.
And I'm not especially bothered by that.
A Useful Kind of Uncertainty
I think we sometimes make a mistake when approaching ancient ideas.
We assume we have to choose between believing them literally and dismissing them entirely.
Either the Muse is an actual supernatural being or she's a fictional character invented by people who didn't understand their own brains.
But why must those be our only options?
A concept can be useful without being literally true.
A metaphor can reveal something about the world without being a physical description of it.
And an ancient practice can have genuine value even if the people who developed it explained its effects differently than we would today.
Perhaps treating the Muse as real encourages humility.
Perhaps it makes us more attentive.
Perhaps it changes our relationship with our own creativity enough that we begin noticing possibilities we would otherwise overlook.
Those are interesting possibilities, even without a goddess.
The important thing is not to confuse the benefits of a belief with proof that the belief is true.
But we don't have to settle every question about reality before allowing an idea to enrich our lives.
Leave the Door Open
I don't know whether the Muse exists.
I don't know whether inspiration is entirely a product of the brain or whether there's some aspect of creativity we haven't adequately explained.
But I do know that some of the most interesting ideas seem to appear when we stop trying to force them into existence.
And I like the idea of treating creativity as something deserving of a little respect.
Something you cultivate a relationship with.
Something you make room for.
Not something you're entitled to command.
Perhaps the Muse is real.
Perhaps she's a useful fiction.
Perhaps the distinction matters less to the creative process than we imagine.
After all, you don't have to know who's knocking to open the door.
And if nobody's there?
Well, you can always sit down and write.
That's probably what the Muse would have wanted anyway.