Field note 040
Seven Laws and a Very Wide Net
I should probably clarify something before we get too far into this.
I don't want to be the occult guy.
I realize that discussing ancient mysteries, hidden knowledge, and the nature of consciousness might give the impression that I spend my evenings sitting inside a chalk circle, attempting to negotiate with something that has too many eyes.
I don't.
Not regularly, anyway.
The truth is that I cast a very wide net when I'm looking for answers. Christianity, Buddhism, physics, philosophy, psychology, mythology. If somebody spent a significant portion of human history trying to figure out what the hell we're doing here, I'm interested in hearing what they came up with.
That includes occult philosophy.
The word occult comes from the Latin for hidden or concealed. Over the centuries, it became associated with esoteric traditions, mystical practices, and various things that would make my grandmother extremely uncomfortable.
But somewhere beneath the robes, symbols, and occasional theatrical nonsense are people asking questions.
What is reality?
What is consciousness?
Why does anything exist?
And why does the universe seem to behave according to patterns that repeat themselves in places where we wouldn't necessarily expect them?
These are not exclusively occult questions.
They're human questions.
And I don't think we should throw away a potentially interesting answer just because somebody wrote it down while wearing a suspicious hat.
Which brings me to the seven Hermetic principles.
A Brief Historical Inconvenience
Before we proceed, there's something worth getting straight.
The seven principles we're about to discuss come from The Kybalion, published anonymously in 1908 under the name "Three Initiates."
The book presents its teachings as expressions of ancient Hermetic wisdom associated with Hermes Trismegistus, a figure with one of the most aggressively impressive names in the history of philosophy.
His story begins when the Greeks encountered Thoth, the Egyptian god of writing, wisdom, and magic, and decided he had quite a bit in common with their own Hermes, the divine messenger and patron of travelers and thieves.
And before my wife asks, no, not the Hermès with the purses. That's a different religion, and I can't afford the initiation fee.
Rather than leave two perfectly good gods alone, the traditions eventually produced Hermes Trismegistus.
The name means "Hermes the Thrice-Great."
Not great. Not even twice-great.
Three times.
You have to admire someone who arrives with his performance review already completed.
Over the centuries, this legendary figure accumulated quite a résumé. He was credited with teachings about God, the cosmos, astrology, alchemy, and the hidden workings of existence. During the Renaissance, European thinkers regarded him as an ancient sage whose wisdom might reach back to the time of Moses.
Entire philosophical and mystical traditions developed around writings attributed to him.
There's just one minor complication.
He probably never existed as a single historical person.
Which is a pretty impressive literary career for someone who may not have existed at all.
I'm jealous.
But there's a distinction between ancient Hermetic philosophy and what three mysterious people—or possibly one particularly productive person—published in the early twentieth century.
The seven principles, as a tidy package, are modern.
That doesn't automatically make them wrong.
It does mean we should resist the temptation to pretend that someone discovered a stone tablet containing the operating instructions for the universe.
People have been doing that sort of thing for centuries.
The universe has yet to include a warranty.
The Universe Is Mental
The first principle is Mentalism.
"The All is Mind; the Universe is Mental."
Well.
That's quite a way to open a book.
The proposition is that reality is fundamentally mental in nature. That what we experience as a physical universe exists within some greater, underlying Mind.
And while I can't say I know whether that's true, it introduces a problem that has occupied an embarrassing amount of my thinking.
We assume consciousness happens inside the universe.
Fair enough.
But every single thing we know about the universe, including the evidence that consciousness happens inside it, arrives through consciousness.
We are attempting to understand the relationship between experience and reality using experience.
It's a little like trying to examine a flashlight with its own beam.
Now, that doesn't mean consciousness creates reality. But it does make me wonder whether we've been too quick to decide which one comes first.
Idealists, mystics, theologians, and philosophers have approached this question from different directions, sometimes arriving at strikingly similar possibilities.
What if individual minds aren't entirely separate from whatever makes experience possible in the first place?
And if that's even remotely plausible, we have another problem.
Where exactly does one thing end and another begin?
As Above, So Below
The second principle is Correspondence.
"As above, so below."
The idea is that patterns at one level of reality may reflect patterns at another.
This is where my longstanding obsession with oceans becomes relevant again.
A wave is a distinguishable thing. We can identify it, measure it, name it, photograph it, and occasionally get knocked unconscious by it.
But where does the wave end and the ocean begin?
At what point does a movement of water become an independent object?
The answer isn't nearly as obvious as our language makes it sound.
A leaf is part of a tree. A person is part of a biological and social system. A wave is something the ocean is doing.
We identify things by drawing boundaries around them, and those boundaries are often useful.
But useful doesn't necessarily mean fundamental.
Of course, similar patterns don't establish some secret cosmic connection between everything that resembles everything else. The world contains plenty of coincidences.
Still, correspondence invites an interesting possibility.
What if some of the divisions we regard as absolute are simply the result of looking at reality from a particular distance?
Zoom in, and you find individuals.
Zoom out, and you find relationships.
Zoom out far enough, and I begin to suspect we might be arguing over which part of the ocean gets to call itself wet.
Apparently, Everything Is Vibrating
The third principle is Vibration.
Everything moves. Everything vibrates. Nothing rests.
This is the principle most likely to make a physicist and a crystal salesman start arguing in a parking lot.
Physical reality certainly contains motion, oscillation, and interactions that are much stranger than everyday appearances suggest.
But somewhere along the way, people decided this meant that positive thinking could influence the universe into delivering a sports car.
I've tried being optimistic about my finances, and the electric company remains stubbornly committed to conventional payment methods.
Nevertheless, there's something remarkable about the underlying observation.
The world we experience as solid and stable is anything but motionless.
Everything is interacting, transforming, or participating in processes that are invisible at the scale of everyday life.
Even the chair you're sitting in is considerably more interesting at the atomic level than it has any right to be.
And yet we spend so much of our lives behaving as though permanence is the natural condition of things.
We build identities around what we are.
We make plans based on what will remain.
We become deeply offended when the universe refuses to hold still.
Which brings us rather conveniently to the next two principles.
The Trouble With Opposites
The fourth principle is Polarity.
The idea is that apparent opposites may be different degrees of the same underlying thing.
Hot and cold, for example, aren't competing substances. They're descriptions of temperature.
Simple enough.
But human beings have an extraordinary talent for turning distinctions into rival civilizations.
Good and bad. Strong and weak. Sacred and profane. Us and them.
We like categories.
Categories make the world manageable.
They also give us somewhere to stand while we throw rocks at the people in the other category.
Now, some differences are real and important. I'm not suggesting that every disagreement can be resolved by announcing that everything is secretly the same thing.
That would be an excellent way to ruin a perfectly good argument without actually resolving it.
But I do wonder how often we mistake our descriptions of reality for reality itself.
How many supposed opposites are actually positions along a continuum?
How many boundaries did we discover?
And how many did we invent?
The distinction matters because once we've named two things as opposites, we become remarkably reluctant to consider that they might belong to the same larger process.
Reality Has Terrible Timing
The fifth principle is Rhythm.
Everything flows. Everything rises and falls. Existence moves through cycles.
Nature gives us plenty of examples.
Days and nights. Seasons. Tides. Growth and decay.
Human experience also contains its share of recurring patterns.
There are periods when everything seems to come together, followed by periods when you begin to suspect the universe has misplaced your paperwork.
I've noticed that we tend to regard the pleasant phases as evidence that life is finally working correctly.
The unpleasant ones are apparently administrative errors.
We want growth without decay. Success without setbacks. Stability without stagnation.
We want the universe to change when we're unhappy and stop changing the moment we're satisfied.
A fairly unreasonable demand, considering the universe was here long before we started submitting requests.
But Rhythm raises a question worth considering.
What if change isn't something that interrupts existence?
What if change is what existence does?
How Much of You Is Actually Yours?
The sixth principle is Cause and Effect.
Things happen because of other things.
Groundbreaking, I know.
But I think this one becomes considerably more interesting when we stop discussing falling dominoes and start discussing ourselves.
Consider how much of the person you call you arrived without your permission.
You didn't choose your parents, your birthplace, your first language, or the century in which you appeared.
You didn't choose the circumstances that shaped your earliest understanding of the world.
Somewhere along the way, an experience changed you. Then another. Then another.
A conversation you barely remember may have influenced a decision that altered the course of your life.
Somebody said something thirty years ago, and you're still carrying it around.
And somehow, at the end of this incomprehensibly complicated chain of events, you arrived at the conclusion that you're an independent individual.
I don't mean that as an argument against free will.
I'm not certain what free will ultimately means, and I'm even less certain that arguing about it will get me anywhere productive before lunch.
But there's something extraordinary about recognizing that we are both consequences of the past and causes of what comes next.
We inherit a world we didn't create.
Then we participate in creating the world someone else will inherit.
Which raises another question.
What exactly does it mean to create something?
The Seventh Principle: Gender
The final principle is Gender.
In Hermetic philosophy, masculine and feminine refer to complementary generative principles understood to operate throughout existence, not simply to men and women. Both are said to exist within everything.
The proposition is that creation involves their interaction.
Something initiates. Something develops. Through the relationship between them, something new emerges.
This one interests me as a writer.
An idea doesn't become a book simply because I had it.
It has to encounter language, imagination, experience, and all the other strange machinery involved in turning something that didn't exist into something that does.
And even then, the process isn't finished.
Somebody else has to encounter it.
They bring an entirely different life into contact with those words.
Whatever happens in their mind is not quite the same thing that happened in mine.
Something new has emerged from the interaction.
But the underlying idea is rather beautiful.
Creation may be less about an isolated force producing something from nothing and more about relationships generating possibilities that didn't previously exist.
Which, come to think of it, brings us all the way back to the beginning.
Mind. Relationships. Movement. Differences. Change. Causes. Creation.
Seven different attempts to describe reality.
And a recurring suggestion that perhaps nothing exists entirely on its own.
So, Are These Laws Actually Laws?
I wouldn't call them established laws of reality.
They're philosophical propositions.
Some are provocative. Some are intuitive. Some are extremely broad. Some become considerably less convincing when people attempt to turn them into scientific explanations.
And a few might reveal more about the human mind than about the universe it inhabits.
But that doesn't make them worthless.
I think there's a peculiar habit we've developed of treating ideas as though examining them requires membership in the organization that produced them.
If I find something interesting in Christianity, that doesn't mean I have to accept every theological claim made by every Christian tradition.
If I find something interesting in Buddhism, I don't have to become Buddhist.
And if I find something interesting in Hermetic philosophy, I don't have to buy a robe and start referring to my living room as the Chamber of Ascension.
I can just think about it.
Imagine that.
I find it especially interesting when traditions separated by centuries and geography arrive at questions that resemble one another.
Not necessarily the same answers.
The same questions.
Perhaps that doesn't tell us anything supernatural.
Perhaps it simply means that human beings, when confronted with existence long enough, eventually begin noticing the same mysteries.
We're all examining the same extraordinarily strange situation from different positions inside it.
A scientist measures it.
A theologian interprets it.
A philosopher questions it.
A mystic experiences something and struggles to explain it.
And occasionally a writer sits at a keyboard, attempting to determine whether the ocean knows what a wave is.
I don't know which of these approaches will get us closest to the truth.
I suspect we'll need more than one.
That's why I cast a wide net.
Not because I believe everything I catch.
But because I'd hate to discover that an answer was swimming right past me while I was busy arguing about which waters were acceptable to fish in.