M. J. ELLIS

Field note 045

Shall We Discuss Aliens?

# Shall We Discuss Aliens?

Well, apparently we're doing this now.

For most of my life, discussing extraterrestrial intelligence was something you did late at night with a friend who owned at least one suspiciously large crystal.

Now we're having congressional hearings.

People with impressive credentials are sitting in front of microphones discussing unidentified objects, alleged recovered technology, and the possibility that our government has been keeping some rather significant secrets.

And humanity has responded with approximately the same level of enthusiasm it brings to a software update.

I find this fascinating.

Not just the alien part.

The us part.

We are a species that has spent thousands of years looking into the night sky, wondering whether we're alone. We've written books about it, made movies about it, invented elaborate mythologies around it, and occasionally built entire religions around the possibility that something up there might be paying attention.

And now that the conversation has become somewhat respectable, we're collectively behaving like someone just told us there's a new manager at the grocery store.

Interesting.

Anyway, what's for dinner?

The Little Green Elephant in the Room

Let me establish something before we go any further.

I don't know whether extraterrestrials have visited Earth.

Neither do most of the people speaking with absolute certainty on the internet, although this has never stopped anyone from speaking with absolute certainty on the internet.

I do think the universe is an awfully large place to contain only one species capable of developing an opinion about itself.

There are hundreds of billions of galaxies in the observable universe, containing staggering numbers of stars and planets.

And somehow, on one unremarkable rock orbiting one unremarkable star, a group of primates developed consciousness, invented microwave popcorn, and decided they were probably the main event.

That's quite a conclusion.

I'm not suggesting extraterrestrial intelligence must exist simply because the universe is enormous. Size alone doesn't establish probability, especially when we don't know how frequently life begins.

But we've explored practically none of the universe.

We don't even know everything living in our own oceans.

Yet we have somehow found time to develop strong opinions about the occupancy of the cosmos.

Bob Lazar and the Container Problem

Which brings me to Bob Lazar.

If you're unfamiliar, Lazar is a man who claimed, beginning in 1989, to have worked on extraterrestrial technology at a secret facility near Area 51.

His story has been controversial for decades. Some details have attracted legitimate interest. Others have serious credibility problems. His central claims remain unverified.

I'm not here to certify the man.

But there is one particular detail from his story that I cannot seem to leave alone.

According to Lazar, briefing material he allegedly encountered referred to human beings as containers.

Containers.

That's an interesting word.

Not people.

Not organisms.

Not intelligent life.

Containers.

Naturally, the internet has interpreted this to mean that our bodies contain souls, which extraterrestrials apparently consider important for reasons nobody has adequately explained.

I'll admit, the idea of technologically advanced beings traveling across interstellar distances to collect human souls raises some logistical questions.

Do they have storage facilities?

Is there a department?

Does someone have to inventory them?

And what, precisely, happens when a shipment of souls arrives damaged?

I have concerns about the paperwork alone.

But I've been thinking about that word.

A container holds something.

An antenna receives something.

And I'm not entirely convinced we know which one we are.

What If We're Antennas?

We generally talk about consciousness as something our brains produce.

And perhaps that's exactly what happens. There is considerable evidence connecting conscious experience to brain activity, injury, chemistry, and neurological function.

But the fundamental question of why physical processes are accompanied by subjective experience remains extraordinarily difficult.

Why is there something it feels like to be you?

Why isn't all this biological machinery simply operating in the dark?

One possibility I've always found interesting is that consciousness might not be manufactured by the brain in quite the way we imagine.

What if the brain functions more like an antenna?

An instrument that receives, filters, or focuses something more fundamental?

I'm not presenting this as established science. There is no demonstrated external consciousness signal waiting to be detected.

It's a thought experiment.

But indulge me.

A radio doesn't create the broadcast it receives.

It translates something already present into a form that can be experienced.

Different receivers produce different results. Some are clearer than others. Some introduce distortion. Some pick up frequencies that others cannot.

And when a radio breaks, the broadcast doesn't necessarily stop.

The instrument simply stops translating it.

Now imagine, just for a moment, that consciousness works something like that.

What we call you might be the particular way an individual brain organizes and experiences something much larger.

Not a soul trapped in a container.

Not a ghost operating a meat puppet.

An individual expression of something that might not be individual at all.

A droplet with a temporary boundary, experiencing what it means to be distinct from the ocean.

Of course, there's a fairly enormous problem with this idea.

We haven't found the broadcast.

We haven't identified the transmitter.

We don't even know whether there's anything to receive.

The analogy is not evidence. It's simply another way of approaching a question we haven't finished answering.

But it makes me wonder whether we've been asking the right one.

Instead of asking whether consciousness survives the body, perhaps we should also ask whether the body is what gives consciousness its particular perspective.

And that distinction is enormous.

Now Bring Back the Aliens

Suppose intelligent extraterrestrial life exists.

What would consciousness look like to them?

Would they experience something equivalent to love, grief, embarrassment, or the sudden realization that they've entered a room and forgotten why?

We tend to imagine extraterrestrials as humans with unusual heads.

They have governments. They have spaceships. They make decisions. They apparently enjoy conducting medical examinations without obtaining consent.

Very rude.

But those assumptions reveal more about our imaginations than about extraterrestrial biology.

We have one example of technological intelligence.

Us.

And we're using that single example to imagine what intelligence must look like everywhere else.

Consider a civilization whose members don't experience themselves as separate individuals.

Not a society where everyone agrees with one another. We've tried that. It usually ends badly.

I mean beings for whom individuality itself is an unfamiliar concept.

Imagine trying to explain loneliness to something that has never experienced separation.

Or trying to explain death to a consciousness that doesn't recognize any meaningful boundary between one life and another.

Perhaps they'd look at us and see more than eight billion different versions of the same thing.

I wonder whether they'd find that beautiful.

Or terribly inefficient.

Or perhaps their understanding of consciousness would be so far beyond ours that our arguments about it would resemble two goldfish debating the existence of water.

I rather like that image.

Two little creatures, suspended in the very thing they're trying to understand, arguing furiously about whether it exists.

One of them has a podcast.

And if consciousness is somehow fundamental to reality rather than merely an accidental byproduct of certain arrangements of matter, the universe could be considerably stranger than our current categories allow.

Not necessarily supernatural.

Just strange.

There's a difference.

The Problem With Wanting to Believe

Here's where I have to be careful.

I want the universe to be astonishing.

I want there to be things out there that force us to reconsider everything we think we understand.

I would be delighted to discover that humanity is the intellectual equivalent of a toddler who has just learned to operate a spoon.

But wanting something to be true is not evidence that it is.

A compelling story isn't proof.

Government secrecy isn't proof of extraterrestrials.

An unidentified object is not automatically a spacecraft.

And a man describing technology beyond our understanding does not establish that the technology exists.

I don't think curiosity requires belief.

And I don't think skepticism requires a closed mind.

Somewhere between the two, there ought to be room to ask an interesting question without immediately having to marry the answer.

I can entertain the possibility that consciousness is fundamental without pretending I've proven it.

I can find Bob Lazar fascinating without deciding he's telling the truth.

And I can wonder whether extraterrestrials have visited Earth without purchasing an emergency supply of aluminum foil.

Although, given the price of groceries, perhaps I should consider buying some anyway.

The point is, I don't need the mystery resolved before I'm allowed to appreciate it.

In fact, I suspect there's something valuable about being able to stand in front of a question and admit that I don't know.

Which brings me back to us.

So, Shall We?

There's something almost tragic about the possibility that humanity could spend thousands of years asking whether we're alone, finally receive an answer, and respond by checking what everyone else is saying about it on their phones.

Perhaps we've become so accustomed to existence that even its greatest mysteries struggle to impress us.

We're here.

Somehow, out of all this matter and energy and apparent emptiness, something has emerged that can look at the universe and wonder what it is.

That alone is astonishing.

And we spend an extraordinary amount of our brief opportunity doing it while worrying about bills, arguing about politics, and trying to remember passwords.

Perhaps extraterrestrial life exists.

Perhaps it has visited us.

Perhaps it knows something about consciousness that would transform our understanding of existence.

Or perhaps we're alone, at least in the small portion of the cosmos we'll ever be able to examine.

I don't know which possibility is stranger.

But I've recently found myself developing a peculiar sense of responsibility toward being alive.

Not an obligation to accomplish something grand.

Not a requirement to justify my existence through productivity or achievement.

Something simpler.

A responsibility to experience this while I can.

To look.

To wonder.

To remain sufficiently humble before existence that I don't mistake the limits of my imagination for the limits of reality.

Maybe consciousness is a broadcast.

Maybe we're containers.

Maybe we're just extraordinarily complicated animals having an extraordinarily unlikely experience.

Whatever the answer, I think the experience deserves a little humility.

And if there really are other minds out there, looking into their own night skies and asking whether they're alone, I hope they find us interesting.

Although, given our current behavior, I would completely understand if they chose to keep driving.

I do have one question for them, though.

What's it like to be you?

Keep reading

What If We're Not as Separate as We Think?

Whose Curiosity Is This, Anyway?

← Back to the journal