Field note 044
The Day My Future Self Stopped Answering
I had been leaving messages for my future self for years.
He had always been polite enough to ignore them.
Then one morning, he wrote back.
Stop making plans that require me.
I stared at the message for a while.
It had appeared beneath a reminder I'd written the night before.
Tomorrow: clean garage, organize files, finish essay, call insurance company.
Nothing particularly ambitious. Just four things I had absolutely no intention of doing that evening.
I assumed the reply was some new artificial intelligence feature. Everything has artificial intelligence now. My phone has artificial intelligence. My television has artificial intelligence. I'm reasonably certain my refrigerator is developing opinions about me.
But the message didn't have the usual cheerful tone of a digital assistant.
It sounded irritated.
Naturally, I responded.
Who is this?
The answer appeared almost immediately.
You.
I considered that.
Which me?
The one you keep assigning things to.
Ah.
That asshole.
I've always had a complicated relationship with my future self.
On the one hand, I have tremendous faith in him.
He's going to be organized. Financially responsible. Physically healthier. Better at managing his time.
He's going to finish all those projects I've started.
He's going to make the phone calls I don't want to make.
He's going to read those books I bought because I wanted to become the sort of person who had read them.
He's going to sort through the mysterious drawer in the kitchen.
You know the drawer.
Every house has one.
It contains batteries of uncertain vitality, keys to doors that may no longer exist, instructions for appliances you've never owned, and at least one object that appears to be a component of a spacecraft.
Future Me will handle it.
He's very capable.
On the other hand, I've never actually met the man.
Which, in retrospect, makes the amount of responsibility I've assigned him seem somewhat unreasonable.
Still, I wasn't prepared to be lectured by someone who owed his entire existence to me.
You're welcome, by the way, I wrote.
For what?
Existing.
There was a pause.
We'll discuss that invoice separately.
I was beginning to dislike him.
The next message arrived with an attachment.
An invoice.
Apparently, my future self had been keeping records.
Outstanding obligations transferred from Present Me:
Garage organization.
Unfinished manuscripts.
Financial planning.
Several difficult conversations.
A collection of minor household repairs.
An alarming number of browser tabs.
And something listed simply as the thing in the closet.
I knew exactly which thing he meant.
I wasn't pleased that he knew, too.
At the bottom was a note.
You keep describing me as the version of us who will have more time.
I won't.
I'll have exactly the same number of hours you do.
They'll just be later.
I read that twice.
Then I did what any reasonable person would do when confronted with an uncomfortable truth.
I began constructing an argument against it.
But things will be different then.
Yes, he replied.
That's generally how time works.
I'll have more money. More experience. Better habits.
Possibly.
I'll know what I'm doing.
He didn't answer that one.
Which was rude.
The conversation continued throughout the afternoon.
I explained that postponing things wasn't necessarily irresponsible. Sometimes circumstances simply weren't right.
He agreed.
I pointed out that people have limited energy.
He agreed with that, too.
I reminded him that rest is important, that not every moment needs to be productive, and that human beings are not machines designed to convert sunlight and anxiety into completed tasks.
He sent back a thumbs-up.
I hate when people do that.
Finally, I decided to challenge his qualifications.
I thought you'd have things figured out by then.
So did I.
That's not encouraging.
Imagine how I feel.
I stared at the screen.
It hadn't occurred to me that Future Me might also be disappointed in Future Me.
That seemed like a serious design flaw.
So you don't have everything figured out?
Do you?
Obviously not. That's why I keep giving you things to do.
And how's that working out?
I was beginning to suspect that whatever wisdom came with age, it didn't necessarily improve your personality.
I asked what exactly he wanted from me.
His response came a few minutes later.
I don't mind doing things.
I mind that you keep promising I'll be a different person.
That stopped me.
What do you mean?
You don't just give me your unfinished work. You give me your expectations.
You expect me to wake up one morning without the doubts you have now. Without the fears. Without the habits. Without the inconvenient parts of being you.
And then you get disappointed in me before I've even arrived.
I put the phone down.
That was an unpleasantly accurate observation from someone who hadn't technically happened yet.
When I picked it back up, the invoice had updated itself.
A new line item had appeared.
Unsolicited personality assignments — ongoing.
I resented how accurately he'd categorized the charge.
I thought about all the versions of myself I'd invented over the years.
The one who would finally get in shape.
The one who would make enough money to stop worrying.
The one who would finish every project.
The one who would understand himself completely.
I'd been waiting for that man for a very long time.
Occasionally, I'd even caught glimpses of him.
A productive week.
A good decision.
A new habit that lasted longer than expected.
And each time, I'd thought, There he is.
Then life would happen.
A setback. An unexpected expense. A bad day.
And I'd decide he'd disappeared again.
But perhaps the problem wasn't that I kept failing to become him.
Perhaps the problem was that I'd invented someone who never had to make a bad decision, experience a setback, or discover that knowing better doesn't always mean doing better.
A man who existed entirely on the other side of every difficulty.
Which was convenient.
For him.
I began to wonder whether there would ever be a finished version of me.
No grand unveiling.
No morning when all the unfinished business of being human had finally been completed.
Just me.
Tomorrow.
Still figuring things out.
And probably still refusing to investigate that kitchen drawer.
I picked up the phone.
So what am I supposed to do? Everything today?
The answer came quickly.
Of course not.
Then what?
Stop treating me like a storage unit.
I laughed.
That was a fair description.
I'd been packing tomorrow full of things I didn't want to carry today, as though the future were an enormous empty warehouse with unlimited capacity.
But tomorrow wouldn't be empty.
There would be new problems. New responsibilities. Unexpected interruptions.
Things breaking.
Things beginning.
There might even be a beautiful afternoon worth wasting.
And there I'd be, arriving with an armful of obligations I'd already decided belonged to someone else.
I can't do everything now, I wrote.
I know.
Some things really do have to wait.
I know that, too.
Then what's your problem?
His reply took longer this time.
You keep deciding what my life is supposed to look like.
I considered that.
Well, somebody has to make plans.
Make plans. Just stop making all of them for me.
What exactly are you planning to do with all this freedom?
I don't know.
You don't know?
No.
That's not much of a plan.
Maybe I'll discover something neither of us has thought of yet.
I frowned.
You're remarkably vague for someone from the future.
You're remarkably confident for someone who isn't.
Fair enough.
What if you make terrible decisions?
Then I suppose I'll have something to complain to the next version of us about.
I laughed again.
For the first time, I began to think of him as something other than a more accomplished version of myself.
He was going to have his own experiences.
His own surprises.
His own ideas.
He might change his mind about things I currently considered essential.
He might even decide that some of my ambitions were ridiculous.
Although I hoped he'd have the decency to keep that to himself.
Another message appeared.
I'd just like you to leave me a little room to live.
I sat with that for a while.
It was an odd request.
After all, he was me.
Wasn't he?
Whatever happened to him would happen to me. Whatever he accomplished, I'd accomplish. Whatever he experienced, I'd experience.
We weren't separate people.
We were the same person, divided by a little time.
And yet I'd been treating him like someone else.
Someone who existed to clean up after me.
Someone whose life I'd already planned, right down to the personality he was supposed to develop.
I'd spent so much of my life trying to build a better future that I'd occasionally forgotten the future was supposed to contain a life.
Not just the results of one.
I looked at my list.
The garage could wait.
The insurance company probably couldn't.
The essay was something I actually wanted to write, which made it rather unfair that I'd started treating it like a dental appointment.
And the mysterious kitchen drawer?
Frankly, some things are better left to archaeology.
I crossed a few items off the list.
Not because they were finished.
Because I'd decided some of them didn't need doing.
It felt strangely different from postponing them.
There was no imaginary person standing at the other end of the decision, waiting to inherit the guilt.
I sent one final message.
I think I understand.
No response.
Are we good?
Nothing.
Hello?
Still nothing.
Apparently, my future self had decided our conversation was over.
I suppose I couldn't blame him.
He probably had things to do.
Later that afternoon, I found myself standing by the front door.
I'd been planning to go outside for several days.
Not for exercise.
Not to accomplish anything.
Just to sit somewhere that wasn't inside the house and enjoy the peculiar fact that the world continued existing without requiring my supervision.
I'd kept putting it off.
There was always something else to do first.
Something important.
Something urgent.
Something that would make it easier to relax later.
I reached for my phone to add it to tomorrow's list.
Then I stopped.
I looked at the door.
Outside, the sun was shining. The afternoon was warm. Somewhere nearby, a bird was making a noise that suggested it had either discovered love or was experiencing a serious mechanical failure.
It seemed like a perfectly good afternoon.
I'd been planning to enjoy one of those eventually.
I figured my future self wouldn't mind if I went first.