Field note 041
The Richest Place in the Universe
Pick a random point in the universe.
You're dead.
Not eventually. Not after a long and fulfilling life. Immediately.
There's no air. The temperature is probably going to be a problem. Depending on where you've landed, radiation, gravity, or the complete absence of anything resembling a habitable environment may also complicate your afternoon.
The universe is an extraordinarily beautiful place to die.
But let's give you a spaceship.
Oxygen. Food. Enough fuel to get around. Everything you need to explore without being immediately converted into a cautionary tale.
Now go anywhere you like.
You could travel across distances so enormous that our brains are almost incapable of appreciating them. Past stars, planets, entire galaxies. Through stretches of space where there is virtually nothing at all.
And for all that magnificent scenery, you might never encounter another living thing.
Not one.
We don't know whether life exists elsewhere. Personally, I hope it does. I find the possibility that we're the only ones here considerably more disturbing than the alternative.
But as far as we've been able to confirm, Earth is the only place in this incomprehensibly enormous universe where anybody is having a conversation.
Think about that.
Almost everywhere else is terrible.
And here we are.
On this tiny planet, you can walk into a grocery store and encounter a dozen other people before you've even made it to the produce.
You can hear somebody laugh.
You can argue with a stranger.
You can fall in love.
You can spend forty years getting to know someone and still have absolutely no idea why they insist on loading the dishwasher that way.
And somehow, we've gotten used to this.
We live surrounded by something we haven't found anywhere else in the universe.
Other people.
Not merely other living organisms.
Other experiences of being alive.
And I think that's where things become genuinely strange.
I've spent a considerable amount of time wondering whether we're actually separate from one another.
I'm beginning to suspect I may have been asking the wrong question.
Which is inconvenient, because I've put quite a lot of work into the first one.
The idea that everything is connected through some underlying reality has fascinated me for years.
One existence expressing itself through countless individual perspectives.
The ocean and its waves. The tree and its leaves.
I've entertained the possibility that what we experience as separate consciousnesses might be expressions of something fundamentally shared.
And I still find that idea compelling.
But lately something has been bothering me.
If we're all one thing, why does it matter that there are so many of us?
I live with my wife and six cats.
That's seven other creatures with their own ideas about how reality should operate, although my wife is the only one who occasionally entertains mine.
I can know her extraordinarily well.
I can understand her habits, recognize her moods, anticipate what she's going to say.
Sometimes.
But no matter how close we become, there's something about her I can never possess.
Her experience.
I will never know exactly what it's like to be her.
I can imagine. I can empathize. I can spend the rest of my life trying to understand.
But there's an entire perspective on existence happening right beside me that I cannot directly experience.
A whole world.
For a long time, I've thought of that distance as a limitation.
Something preventing complete understanding.
But suppose the distance disappeared.
Suppose I could experience everything she experiences.
Every thought. Every sensation. Every memory. Every private association.
Suppose there were no meaningful difference between her experience and mine.
Would that bring us closer?
Perhaps.
But at what point would there stop being two people?
And if there were no longer two people, what would become of the relationship?
That's what troubles me.
Because I've always thought of love as a kind of connection.
But connection seems to require something to connect.
You can't discover someone who has nothing you don't already know.
You can't be surprised by a perspective indistinguishable from your own.
And you can't encounter another person if, in every meaningful sense, there is no other person to encounter.
It's beginning to look as though the very distinction I've spent years trying to see past might be necessary for some of the things I value most.
I wasn't expecting that.
The philosopher Martin Buber explored something related to this in his distinction between I–It and I–Thou.
I'm simplifying considerably, but the idea that interests me is the difference between treating someone as an object within your experience and genuinely encountering them as another being.
Consider the cashier at the grocery store.
Most of the time, they're simply part of the process.
You need groceries. They scan groceries. Money changes hands. Everyone goes home.
But occasionally something interrupts the arrangement.
The cashier says something unexpected.
Maybe they make a joke. Maybe you notice something in their expression that makes you ask whether they're okay.
And suddenly you're aware of something you hadn't been considering.
There's somebody over there.
A whole person.
They were having thoughts before you arrived. They'll continue having them after you leave.
They have memories, fears, people they love, things they regret, and an entire history that has absolutely nothing to do with you.
For a moment, the scenery looks back.
And I find that astonishing.
Here is another experience of being alive, every bit as immediate to them as yours is to you.
A world you can encounter but never completely enter.
Now consider what that might mean for the idea of some underlying unity.
I've often treated the possibility that we're all connected as though discovering that connection would somehow make our differences less significant.
But why?
If every individual perspective were an expression of the same underlying reality, those perspectives wouldn't necessarily become meaningless.
Quite the opposite.
Their differences might be among the most extraordinary things that reality is capable of producing.
Perhaps unity and individuality aren't competing explanations.
Perhaps I've been treating them as opposites when they never had to be.
And if you want to involve God, which I frequently do, that presents an interesting possibility.
Suppose existence really is an expression of something divine.
Suppose beneath all these separate lives there is some fundamental unity.
Why assume the purpose of individuality is to eventually overcome it?
Why assume that returning to the Source would be more meaningful than the astonishing variety of experiences already taking place?
Maybe the important thing isn't that everything could ultimately be one.
Maybe it's that whatever exists can be one without being the same.
And perhaps that's precisely what makes an encounter possible.
Not two things becoming identical.
Two distinct experiences meeting without either having to disappear.
I find that possibility rather beautiful.
And it brings me back to our unfortunate astronaut.
Imagine owning an entire galaxy.
Every star belongs to you. Every planet. Every mountain, ocean, and spectacular alien sunset.
You've accumulated more material wealth than any human being could possibly comprehend.
And you're completely alone.
There's nobody to share any of it with.
Nobody to surprise you.
Nobody to challenge you.
Nobody to introduce a thought that could never have occurred to you.
Nobody to look back.
It's difficult to imagine a poorer arrangement.
Now consider what we have here.
Billions of people.
Billions of experiences.
An almost incomprehensible abundance of other perspectives, happening simultaneously on a small planet in a universe where almost every other place we know about would kill us.
And we've become so accustomed to this extraordinary circumstance that we sometimes experience the presence of other people primarily as an inconvenience.
I don't mean that other people are always wonderful.
They aren't.
I also don't mean that money and material security are unimportant. I've experienced enough financial difficulty to develop a very sincere appreciation for both.
But I wonder whether we've overlooked an entire category of wealth.
The existence of someone else.
Someone who can understand something you cannot.
Someone who can see something you've missed.
Someone who can choose to love you, precisely because they aren't simply another version of you.
I've spent years looking for what connects us beneath our apparent differences.
I still want to know what's there.
But I think I've neglected something rather important about those differences.
They make it possible for reality to contain someone other than me.
And in a universe almost entirely composed of places where we can't even survive, we've found ourselves somewhere we can meet.
I hope there are other places like this.
I really do.
But for now, this is the only one we know about.
And I think that's an extraordinary bit of luck.