M. J. ELLIS

Field note 050

The First Conspiracy Was Christmas

Remember when you found out about Santa Claus?

Not when you first became suspicious. I mean the actual moment you knew.

Maybe you found the presents in a closet. Maybe you recognized your mother's handwriting on the gift tags. Maybe some little asshole at school decided that if he couldn't have magic anymore, neither could you.

However it happened, something changed.

For me, it happened three days before Christmas.

I was in the third grade, sitting in a tree outside my grandmother's front door, having what I believed was a perfectly ordinary conversation about Christmas.

Unfortunately, the conversation included a neighborhood kid who had already established himself as something of a professional pain in the ass.

You know the type.

Always running his mouth. Always something to say. The sort of kid who seemed to wake up every morning determined to make himself somebody else's problem.

Anyway, we're talking about Christmas when this little bastard looks up at me and says:

"You know your mom is Santa, right?"

Excuse me?

How dare this little asshole imply that my mother was fat?

I jumped out of that tree and punched him in his stupid mouth.

Now, I realize that violence is not generally considered an appropriate response to theological disagreement.

But from my perspective, there hadn't been a theological disagreement.

Someone had insulted my mother.

And I had defended her honor.

Naturally, he ran home to tell on me.

Snitch.

This presented a minor administrative problem. I knew his report would eventually reach my mother, so I decided to get ahead of the situation.

Surely she would understand.

After all, I hadn't started a fight over something stupid. I'd been defending her good name against a vicious accusation concerning her physical resemblance to a large elderly man.

Frankly, I expected some appreciation.

So I went to my mother and explained what had happened.

I told her what the boy had said.

And instead of expressing gratitude for my courageous defense of her honor, she sighed.

"Oh, honey. Sit down. I've got to tell you..."

She explained that Santa Claus wasn't actually a real person delivering presents. It was something parents did to make Christmas magical for their kids.

And now that I knew, it was important that I not go around telling the other kids.

The usual speech, I suppose.

Except I wasn't processing any of it the way she probably expected.

My mind was reeling.

Not because I'd discovered my mom had been lying to me.

Not because Christmas had lost its magic.

Not even because Santa Claus apparently didn't exist.

No.

That little fucker had been RIGHT.

I had jumped out of a tree and punched a kid in the mouth for telling me the truth.

And now I looked like an idiot.

Worse, I couldn't even go back and argue with him.

He knew.

I knew.

My mother knew.

And apparently every adult on the planet knew.

I had somehow managed to be both the last person informed and the only person who'd committed an act of violence over the misunderstanding.

And to make matters worse, my mother had just informed me that I wasn't allowed to tell anybody else.

So now I was expected to maintain the conspiracy that had just made a fool of me.

Wonderful.

Welcome to adulthood, apparently.

And I don't think we talk enough about how strange that moment actually was.

Consider what I'd just discovered.

My mom had been telling me something that wasn't true. My grandmother and uncles were involved. My teachers had apparently signed some sort of agreement. There were songs, movies, books, television specials, and an entire retail industry dedicated to maintaining the illusion.

They even had a guy at the mall.

This wasn't some little white lie.

This was an international conspiracy with seasonal staffing.

And I'd believed it.

Of course I'd believed it. Why wouldn't I? My mother was the person who taught me what was real, and she'd been telling me that an elderly man was flying around the planet in a sleigh pulled by livestock.

And somehow, every December, he made it through American airspace without being intercepted.

At the time, I was mostly concerned with the fact that I'd punched the only person in the conversation who knew what he was talking about.

But looking back, that afternoon introduced a much more unsettling possibility.

The world could be different from what everyone said it was.

People I loved could tell me something untrue. Entire communities could agree to behave as though something existed when it didn't. Evidence could be manufactured. Eyewitness testimony could be unreliable.

And a neighborhood asshole could be absolutely correct.

That last part was particularly difficult to accept.

But there was another question nobody seemed particularly interested in answering.

If everybody knew this wasn't true, why had they all been doing it?

As a kid, the obvious explanation was that adults were terrible people who enjoyed making fools of us.

And frankly, considering how much fun they had with the whole thing, the evidence wasn't entirely against that conclusion.

But here's something I find even stranger.

Nobody actually organized this conspiracy.

Our modern Christmas traditions are an enormous collection of stories and customs that people have been borrowing, modifying, and passing along for centuries.

Santa Claus himself is something of a historical group project.

He began, in part, with Saint Nicholas, a fourth-century bishop associated with generosity and gift-giving. Throw in the Dutch Sinterklaas, the English Father Christmas, an 1823 poem about flying reindeer, and a nineteenth-century cartoonist named Thomas Nast, and the familiar figure starts taking shape.

Meanwhile, the Germans contributed Christmas trees, and Queen Victoria helped make them fashionable in Britain.

Then Coca-Cola came along in the 1930s and helped popularize Santa's modern image.

They didn't invent him, despite what you may have heard.

They just gave him an extraordinarily successful advertising campaign.

A fourth-century bishop eventually became a celebrity spokesperson for carbonated sugar water.

History is magnificent.

And somehow, across centuries and continents, millions of people agreed to keep the whole thing going.

No headquarters.

No governing board.

Just generation after generation of adults participating in the same beautiful, ridiculous fiction.

And then something happened to me that made the whole arrangement considerably more complicated.

I became a father.

And eventually, I became Santa Claus.

For my son, I participated in exactly the same conspiracy that had once been carried out against me.

I did the standard stuff.

There was the eight o'clock Santa tracker on the news. Which, as you eventually discover, is an elaborate ruse perpetrated by the news media to convince kids that Santa is approaching their geographical location and they'd better get their asses to bed.

An impressive feat of psychological manipulation, really.

Millions of kids voluntarily going to bed early because a television station put a cartoon sleigh on a map.

Then there was the Elf on the Shelf.

For the uninitiated, this is a small elf doll supposedly sent by Santa to observe the behavior of kids and report back to the North Pole. Parents secretly move it around the house every night to make it appear that the little bastard is alive and conducting surveillance.

Because apparently the idea of an omniscient old man judging your behavior wasn't unsettling enough.

We needed an informant inside the house.

And then there was our Christmas tree.

My son and I had a tiny tree that we decorated together every year, just the two of us, while the cookies for Santa were being made.

That little tree was ours.

And I'm ashamed to admit that I took part in those cookies.

A Eucharist of lies.

All these years after discovering the conspiracy, there I was, actively participating in its most sacred rituals.

I'd been promoted from unwilling witness to management.

Suddenly, the whole operation looked different.

The presents didn't materialize. Somebody bought them. Somebody worked the hours that paid for them. Somebody stayed awake until midnight assembling a plastic nightmare with forty-seven pieces and instructions apparently translated from ancient Sumerian.

All that effort, all that planning, all those exhausted adults sneaking around their own houses.

And then, on Christmas morning, they handed the credit to a man who wasn't even there.

Think about that.

The people responsible for the magic deliberately removed themselves from it.

They created something wonderful and then pretended someone else had done it.

And the kids believed them.

Of course, the arrangement has one rather significant design flaw.

Eventually, other kids start asking questions on their behalf.

And eventually, I had to tell my son.

He was getting ready to go into the fifth grade.

Which, looking back, was probably a little too old for the operation to remain classified.

We were having lunch at a Wendy's. I was asking him about school, and he mentioned that some kid had been making fun of him for believing in Santa Claus.

Shit.

I'd let this go on too long.

My son was getting made fun of for believing something I had spent years convincing him was true.

Looking back, the symmetry is difficult to miss.

Different kid. Different year.

Same Santa Claus problem.

Apparently, this conspiracy had a way of coming back around.

I don't remember exactly what I said next.

I just remember giving him the entire operational rundown.

The whole thing.

Years of carefully maintained mythology, dismantled over lunch at a fast-food restaurant.

And he just stared at me.

I'll never forget that stare.

When I finally finished, he had one question.

"But why?"

And there it was.

The question I should probably have been prepared to answer.

After all, I'd been participating in this operation for years. I'd helped maintain the illusion, perpetuated the story, and recruited a small decorative elf into a domestic surveillance program.

Surely I had a good explanation.

I didn't.

I remember saying something to the effect of:

"I don't know, man. It's supposed to make Christmas fun for you. But it's also a good lesson. People are going to tell you things you don't believe, and it's up to you to use your own judgment and discernment to decide what's true and what isn't."

God, I fucked that up royally.

There I was, trying to teach my son the importance of critical thinking while explaining that I'd spent the better part of a decade deliberately misleading him.

Apparently, the lesson was that you should question everything.

Especially your father.

I suppose that's partly why I sat down to write this.

Which seems like a good opportunity to make a formal statement.

Son, I'm sorry.

I participated in a multigenerational conspiracy to misrepresent the capabilities of an elderly man and several flying mammals.

I knowingly furnished misleading information concerning the manufacture, transportation, and delivery of consumer goods.

I cannot confirm the existence of elves.

And I am now prepared to admit that the entire North Pole operation suffered from serious transparency issues.

In my defense, everybody else was doing it.

Which, I realize, is not generally considered a strong defense.

But there's something else I want to say.

Something I didn't understand when I was the kid finding out.

Was Santa Claus actually a lie?

Obviously, the man at the North Pole wasn't operating an overnight global delivery service.

I'm comfortable making that claim.

And yes, that means the story we told our kids was untrue. Good intentions don't change that.

But the experience was real.

The excitement was real. The anticipation was real. The strange feeling that the world might contain something extraordinary, something beyond ordinary explanation, was real.

And the people creating those experiences were real.

So what, exactly, disappeared when we learned the truth?

The story?

Or just our understanding of who was telling it?

I think about that sometimes when I consider how much of human life is organized around stories.

Money works because we agree that it does. Nations exist partly because we collectively recognize their boundaries. Traditions survive because people keep performing them.

And fiction?

Well, fiction is an arrangement of words describing people who never existed, doing things that never happened, in places nobody has ever visited.

Yet somehow those arrangements can make us cry.

Or fall in love.

Or reconsider everything we thought we knew.

Something doesn't have to be literally true to produce something real.

That doesn't mean truth is irrelevant. Quite the opposite. Finding out about Santa was probably one of our earliest lessons in why it matters.

And telling my son the truth was part of being his father, too.

Because the magic eventually has to survive the explanation.

Perhaps we learned two things from Santa Claus.

First, that we shouldn't believe something simply because everyone else does.

And second, that human beings are capable of deliberately creating wonder for one another.

The second lesson just took a little longer to appreciate.

I suppose that's what growing up does.

At first, you think magic is something that happens to you.

Then you discover that someone has been making it happen.

And eventually, if you're lucky, you get the opportunity to make a little yourself.

It's considerably less glamorous than the original arrangement.

There are receipts involved.

But I think I understand Santa Claus better now than I did when I believed in him.

Not because I've found a way to make the reindeer fly.

But because I've begun to appreciate how extraordinary it is that people would go to all that trouble just to give somebody else a moment of wonder.

And maybe that's what I really owe my son an apology for.

Not for wanting to make Christmas wonderful.

For letting the story go on so long that other kids got to make fun of him for believing it.

That part was on me.

I wish I'd had a better answer in that Wendy's.

I think the best one I've got now is that I wanted him to experience a little wonder, and I didn't quite know when to let him in on how it was made.

When I think about those Christmases, I remember our little tree.

Just the two of us, decorating it while the cookies were being made.

No flying reindeer. No elves. No elaborate surveillance operation.

Just a father and his son making something wonderful out of an ordinary evening.

That part was real.

Because the truth is that the magic wasn't hiding at the North Pole.

It was being made by tired people who could have gone to bed.

Keep reading

Who Gets to Remember Us?

Your Worst Day Is Still Your Worst Day

← Back to the journal