M. J. ELLIS

Field note 048

Who Gets to Remember Us?

Achilles had a plan.

It wasn't a particularly good plan, but it was ambitious.

Die young. Become famous. Stay famous forever.

Essentially, the man invented dying for exposure.

In Homer's Iliad, Achilles describes a choice between two futures. He can return home, enjoy a long life, and eventually be forgotten. Or he can remain at Troy, die young, and achieve everlasting glory.

The Greeks had a word for this: kleos.

Glory. Renown. The kind of reputation that survives because people keep telling stories about you.

And here's the irritating part.

It worked.

Thousands of years later, I'm sitting here discussing Achilles instead of doing something productive.

The son of a bitch is still getting publicity.

Now, I understand the appeal.

Death is a fairly significant inconvenience. For starters, it makes scheduling difficult. And the idea that everything we've experienced, learned, loved, and suffered through might eventually disappear without so much as a forwarding address is understandably upsetting.

So humans have developed a few strategies.

We build monuments.

We have children.

We write books.

We name buildings after ourselves.

Occasionally we commission enormous statues, which seems like a perfectly reasonable response to the realization that we're temporary.

Some people want their names carved into history.

Others just want their grandchildren to remember their birthdays.

But lately I've been wondering whether we're approaching this from the wrong direction.

What if being remembered and continuing to exist in the world are two entirely different things?

Consider this.

Somewhere in ancient Greece, while Achilles was busy cultivating an absolutely legendary reputation for anger management problems, an ordinary woman was probably comforting a frightened child.

No battlefield. No heroic speech. No divine intervention.

Just a mother holding her child and making the world feel a little less terrifying.

Nobody wrote an epic poem about it.

Homer was apparently occupied with a muscular man refusing to come out of his tent.

But imagine that child growing up.

Maybe she has children of her own. And when one of them gets frightened, she instinctively does something her mother used to do.

Perhaps she doesn't even realize where she learned it.

A few generations pass.

Then a few more.

Eventually nobody remembers the original woman.

Her name is gone. Her house is gone. Everything she owned has returned to the earth or been dug up by somebody with a brush and a university grant.

And yet somewhere, somebody might still be doing something differently because she existed.

I find that fascinating.

Because it suggests we're not nearly as contained within our own lives as we like to imagine.

Take my wife.

When we met, we were two reasonably distinct human beings, each equipped with our own opinions, habits, insecurities, and deeply questionable methods of loading a dishwasher.

Then something strange happened.

We started becoming each other.

Not entirely. Thank God. The world is barely prepared for one of me.

But gradually, almost imperceptibly, pieces of her began turning up in my thinking.

I notice things I wouldn't have noticed before.

I consider perspectives that once would never have occurred to me.

Sometimes I hear myself expressing an opinion and realize that, somewhere along the way, I've acquired one of hers.

She has effectively been renovating my personality without obtaining the necessary permits.

And I suspect I've done the same to her.

We move into each other's heads and start rearranging the furniture.

And the truly strange part is that after enough time, you can't always remember what the place looked like before the other person arrived.

Now multiply that by everyone you've ever known.

Your parents. Your friends. Your teachers. The person who said something to you in third grade that you've never forgotten.

The stranger who was unexpectedly kind.

The asshole who made you feel small.

They're all in there.

Some brought furniture.

Some knocked holes in the walls.

A few should have been evicted decades ago.

And this is where things get interesting, because not all of those people are still alive.

Yet here they are, influencing decisions, shaping reactions, occasionally saying things through your mouth that make you stop and think:

Jesus Christ. I've become my father.

There's a horror story hiding in that sentence, by the way.

But there's also something beautiful.

We seem to have a remarkably difficult time leaving other people's lives without leaving something of ourselves behind.

Not deliberately.

Not always beneficially.

We just can't help it.

We enter someone's life, change something, and leave.

Then they change someone else.

And someone else.

And eventually the original influence has traveled so far from its source that nobody could possibly trace it back.

It's like a philosophical game of telephone, except instead of getting the message wrong, everyone becomes slightly different.

Which brings me back to Achilles.

He wanted immortality through remembrance.

And he got it, at least in the sense that we still remember the character and tell his story.

Congratulations, Achilles.

Your name survived.

But I wonder how many completely forgotten people have left behind something far more substantial than a name.

Some unknown person taught another person compassion.

Someone invented a joke that made a miserable afternoon bearable.

Someone was kind to a child who grew up and became kind to someone else.

Someone changed the way another human being understood love.

And then they died.

And their name disappeared.

But the consequences didn't.

The more I think about this, the stranger it gets.

Because if I am partly made of people who came before me, and the people I influence will carry some altered version of me into their own lives, then where exactly do I end?

At my skin?

At my last breath?

At the final person who remembers my name?

Or does some tiny, unrecognizable contribution of mine keep traveling through the world long after every trace of my biography has disappeared?

I'm not sure immortality is even the right word.

But I am becoming increasingly suspicious of our insistence that a person ends quite so neatly.

Perhaps we aren't just individuals.

Perhaps we're also intersections.

Places where thousands of other lives meet, collide, exchange information, make a terrible mess, and send something new out into the world.

And if that's true, then we're all walking around carrying pieces of people we've never met.

Some of them have been dead for centuries.

Some of them were probably idiots.

A few might have been extraordinary.

We'll never know.

But I like imagining that somewhere in the world, a person is showing kindness to a frightened child because, hundreds of years ago, someone whose name has been lost did exactly the same thing.

Achilles got his immortality.

He made sure the world would remember his name.

But somewhere, some completely forgotten person may still be changing the world.

And unlike Achilles, they didn't even have to kill anybody to do it.

Keep reading

What If We're Not as Separate as We Think?

The Richest Place in the Universe

← Back to the journal