M. J. ELLIS

Field note 013

The Most Dangerous Word in Nonfiction Is “Still”

By M. J. Ellis

A fact can be true, useful, and obsolete before the sentence containing it reaches print.

That's an uncomfortable thought when you're trying to write nonfiction.

Fiction is wonderfully forgiving. You can invent a man named Gerald, have him announce that he's God, and spend an entire book making him defend that claim. Nobody can demand his birth certificate. Nobody can produce a peer-reviewed study demonstrating that Gerald does not exist.

Well, somebody probably can. The internet is a remarkable place.

But nonfiction comes with a different responsibility.

When you tell someone something is true, you're asking them to carry that information out into the world. They might repeat it. They might use it to make a decision. They might build an entire opinion around it.

And if you're wrong, your mistake gets to travel without you.

The Little Word That Changes Everything

Consider a sentence:

This is how doctors treat the condition.

Perfectly reasonable. Except that the sentence has a hidden expiration date.

Now add one word:

This is still how doctors treat the condition.

That little word makes a much larger promise.

It says someone checked. It says the information survived whatever happened between the original discovery and the moment you encountered it.

It says the world has been consulted recently.

And that's a hell of a promise to make.

Medicine changes. Laws change. Technology changes. Historical interpretations change as new evidence emerges. Even our understanding of things that happened centuries ago can shift because someone opens a forgotten archive, translates a document, or notices that the original expert was making things up.

Sometimes the change is dramatic.

Sometimes it's a tiny correction buried in a journal nobody reads unless they're being paid to.

Either way, yesterday's perfectly respectable fact can become today's confidently delivered bullshit.

The dangerous part isn't necessarily that somebody lied.

It's that nobody checked whether the truth had moved.

The Problem With Being Right

We tend to imagine misinformation as something produced by dishonest people.

And sure, there's plenty of that.

But some misinformation begins with someone doing everything right.

They find a reputable source. They verify a claim. They write it down accurately. They cite it properly.

Then time passes.

A new study challenges the original. A professional organization revises its guidance. A once-accepted explanation becomes more complicated.

The writer's sentence hasn't changed.

The world has.

This creates a particularly irritating problem for anyone who takes research seriously: being correct when you write something doesn't guarantee you'll be correct when someone reads it.

Which means nonfiction writing isn't just about collecting facts.

It's about understanding what kind of facts you're collecting.

Some are remarkably durable. The Earth orbits the Sun. Water molecules contain hydrogen and oxygen. Humans have an extraordinary talent for turning minor disagreements into international incidents.

Other claims are provisional. They represent our best current explanation, our most effective available treatment, or the prevailing interpretation of incomplete evidence.

Those aren't bad facts.

They're simply facts that come with moving parts.

And a responsible writer ought to tell you where the moving parts are.

The Dead Are Terrible at Updating Their Work

There's another problem I've been thinking about lately.

What happens when the person who originally wrote something isn't around to explain it?

Imagine finding an old manual.

Not a polished, modern book. Something personal. Handwritten, maybe. Full of practical advice, observations, mistakes, and the unmistakable personality of whoever assembled it.

Some of it is brilliant.

Some of it is outdated.

Some of it might be dangerous if someone mistakes historical practice for modern guidance.

Now imagine you're responsible for bringing that work to new readers.

What do you do?

You could rewrite everything according to current knowledge.

But then whose book is it?

You could preserve every word exactly as written.

But then what responsibility do you have when a reader encounters advice that shouldn't be followed anymore?

You could bury the whole thing in footnotes until it resembles a legal deposition with occasional moments of personality.

Congratulations. You've preserved the information and murdered the reading experience.

The more I think about it, the more convinced I become that preservation and correction are two different jobs.

The original writer deserves to be represented accurately.

The reader deserves to know what remains accurate.

Neither responsibility cancels the other.

A historical claim shouldn't be quietly rewritten to make its author seem prophetic. A questionable recommendation shouldn't be presented as safe merely because it was sincere. And an editor shouldn't pretend that correcting a fact gives them permission to replace someone's voice with their own.

Sometimes the most respectful thing you can do for an old piece of writing is leave the original intact and explain where the world has moved on.

The dead cannot update their work.

The living can at least stop pretending they did.

Certainty Is a Terrible Editor

There's something seductive about a sentence that sounds absolutely certain.

Scientists have proven...

Experts agree...

Research shows...

Those phrases can be perfectly legitimate.

They can also function as little costumes we put on uncertainty to make it look respectable.

I like a strong statement. I like an argument with teeth. I don't particularly enjoy reading a paragraph that apologizes for existing.

But confidence and accuracy are not the same thing.

A writer can be forceful without pretending the evidence is stronger than it is.

There's an enormous difference between saying, "This is the best explanation supported by current evidence," and saying, "This is unquestionably how the universe works."

The first sentence invites examination.

The second invites the universe to make an asshole out of you.

And the universe has an excellent record.

I write about consciousness, identity, death, religion, and the strange business of being alive. These aren't exactly subjects famous for producing universally agreed-upon answers.

If anything, the more I research them, the more suspicious I become of anyone who claims to have everything settled.

Including myself.

Especially myself.

A Book Is Not a Tombstone

I don't think nonfiction needs to be timid.

Quite the opposite.

I want books that make claims, challenge assumptions, take risks, and occasionally make the reader put the thing down and stare at a wall.

I want writers to have opinions.

I want them to be funny, furious, curious, irreverent, and unmistakably human.

But I also want them to understand the difference between an argument and a fact.

An argument can survive disagreement.

A fact has to survive verification.

And sometimes verification means discovering that the sentence you loved most in the entire chapter is wrong.

That's a miserable experience.

You spend an hour making it elegant. You arrange the words just right. You give it rhythm. You make it funny.

Then some inconsiderate researcher publishes evidence that ruins everything.

The bastard.

But you have to change it.

Because the point of researching something isn't to collect enough evidence to defend what you already wanted to say.

It's to find out whether you should be saying it at all.

That's the bargain.

The writing can be entertaining. The voice can be unmistakable. The argument can be uncomfortable.

But the facts don't belong to the author.

They belong to reality.

And reality retains editing privileges.

Still

There's a question I think every nonfiction writer should ask before publishing:

If I checked this again today, would I still write the same sentence?

Not because every fact changes overnight.

Not because certainty is impossible.

And certainly not because we should all surrender to the exhausting idea that nobody can know anything.

We can know things.

We know an extraordinary number of things.

Humanity has spent thousands of years building an increasingly sophisticated understanding of the world, occasionally interrupted by our insistence on setting each other on fire.

That knowledge matters.

But knowledge isn't a collection of sacred sentences preserved forever under glass.

It's a process.

A continuous, imperfect, frequently embarrassing process of discovering what we got wrong and trying to do better.

Which brings me back to that little word.

Still.

Five letters that ask whether something survived the passage of time.

Five letters that turn an old claim into a current responsibility.

Maybe that's what good nonfiction ultimately requires.

Not a writer who never gets anything wrong.

A writer who cares enough to find out when they have.

And who is willing to change the sentence.

Even when it was a really good sentence.


Probably Nothing — M. J. Ellis

Strange questions. Uncomfortable answers. Occasional profanity.

Read next

What did this bring up for you?

A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.

Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.
Back to the journal