M. J. ELLIS

Field note 049

The Universe Does Not Fit Through My Face

I've recently become suspicious of my face.

Not for the usual reasons. Although it has certainly given me a few.

No, my concern is that I've been trusting it to tell me what reality looks like, and I'm beginning to think this is an unreasonable amount of responsibility to place on something that grows nose hair.

Think about it.

Everything you've ever seen, heard, smelled, tasted, or touched has arrived through a relatively small collection of biological equipment. Your brain takes those signals, assembles them into something recognizable, and presents the finished product as the world.

And we believe it.

Of course we do. What else are we going to do?

But there's a problem.

We know perfectly well that our senses don't show us everything.

Our eyes detect a tiny fraction of the electromagnetic spectrum. Our ears respond to a limited range of frequencies. Even the five senses we learned about in school turn out to be an incomplete inventory. We've also got systems for balance, body position, and various things happening inside us.

Fine. We've got more than five.

My complaint stands.

Whatever the final number turns out to be, those are the senses we have. And we've been using them to make some pretty sweeping declarations about the nature of existence.

In 1974, a philosopher named Thomas Nagel asked a deceptively simple question:

What is it like to be a bat?

Bats navigate their surroundings using echolocation. They emit sounds and interpret the returning echoes to locate objects, obstacles, and occasionally dinner.

We understand how that works.

We can explain the physics. We can build machines that accomplish something similar.

But Nagel pointed out that understanding how a bat perceives the world doesn't tell us what experiencing that world actually feels like to the bat.

Go ahead. Imagine being a bat.

You're probably picturing yourself flying around in the dark, listening to echoes, maybe eating an insect against your better judgment.

Congratulations.

You've imagined being a human with wings and an unusually sophisticated parking sensor.

You haven't imagined being a bat.

And that's where things start getting interesting.

Bees perceive ultraviolet patterns on flowers that are invisible to us. Sharks detect electrical fields. Some birds can use information from Earth's magnetic field to navigate.

Same planet. Same physical reality. Remarkably different experiences of it.

Now imagine trying to explain the color red to a creature that has never possessed sight.

You could explain wavelengths. You could describe the behavior of light. You could explain everything we know about the physics involved.

But could you give that creature the experience of red?

Probably not.

Now turn the question around.

What's our equivalent of red?

What if there's some aspect of reality that we don't perceive, not because it's especially well hidden, but because we simply don't possess the equipment?

And I don't necessarily mean another color, another sound, or some extraordinary ability to smell what the neighbors had for dinner.

Those are just variations on things we already understand.

I'm wondering about something more fundamental.

An entirely different category of experience.

Something as unlike sight as sight is unlike taste.

Try imagining one.

Seriously.

Take a moment.

Notice what your brain does.

It probably invents some new kind of light. Or a vibration. Or an energy field. Or a mysterious sensation traveling through your body.

We've barely begun imagining an unfamiliar sense, and already we're dragging our existing ones into the room wearing fake mustaches.

Our imagination has a parts inventory.

We build monsters with teeth we've seen, futures with clocks we understand, and even when we invent angels, we give them wings borrowed from birds.

What happens when the thing we're trying to imagine doesn't have any parts in common with our experience?

Suppose there were a creature that experienced relationships as directly as we experience temperature.

Not reading facial expressions. Not interpreting behavior. Not telepathy.

Something else entirely.

Two people enter a room, and this creature immediately experiences the nature of their connection as some fundamental quality of the space around it.

Love. Resentment. History. Something neither person even realizes exists.

Or perhaps some creature experiences time as a whole, rather than one moment after another.

We can imagine these possibilities, at least approximately.

But notice what we've done.

We've borrowed temperature, relationships, and shapes. We've taken familiar experiences and rearranged the furniture.

I can't actually describe an entirely unfamiliar category of experience.

That's rather the point.

And here's something that bothers me even more.

We wouldn't necessarily know we were missing it.

Imagine an entire species born without sight.

Not a civilization of blind people who have heard about vision from people who possess it. A species that has never seen anything. Ever.

No creature on its planet has eyes.

No one has witnessed a sunset. No one has described a color. No one has complained about the wallpaper.

They might develop remarkable technologies. They might understand matter, energy, mathematics, and the laws of nature.

Perhaps they'd even discover electromagnetic radiation. They could measure it, harness it, or translate it into sound or touch.

But would any of that tell them that radiation could be experienced as color?

And even if they suspected such an experience was possible, would they have the slightest idea what they were missing?

Now imagine explaining sight to them.

"There's this thing called color."

"What's color?"

"Well, it's something you see."

"What's seeing?"

"It's how you experience light."

"What's experiencing light?"

And there you are.

Trying to explain blue to a civilization that doesn't even have a word for looking.

They might understand every equation you showed them.

They might build instruments capable of measuring wavelengths more precisely than anything we've ever constructed.

They might know more about light than we do.

And still have absolutely no idea what blue is like.

Now imagine that we're those people.

What would we look for?

How would we know where to point the instruments?

What if there are questions we haven't asked because we don't possess the experiences that would make those questions occur to us?

That possibility seems considerably stranger than the idea of something hiding from us.

A secret can be discovered.

But what about something you don't even know constitutes a secret?

We tend to imagine that the universe is filled with things we haven't found yet.

More planets. More particles. More life. More explanations.

And perhaps it is.

But all those discoveries fit into categories we already recognize.

Things. Places. Forces. Events.

What if some portion of reality doesn't fit our categories at all?

Not because it's magical.

Not because it exists in another dimension.

But because the categories themselves belong to the particular kind of creature doing the investigating.

And now consider something even stranger.

What if the limits of our senses have also shaped our assumptions about what it means to exist?

We experience ourselves as individuals. Separate bodies, separate minds, each occupying a particular place at a particular time.

It's difficult to imagine existence working any other way.

But is that because individuality is the only possible form of conscious experience?

Or because it's the only form we know how to have?

I'm not suggesting that we're secretly one giant consciousness, or that the universe is waiting for us to discover some cosmic sixth-sense organ behind our left ears.

Although if there is one, I'd appreciate somebody pointing it out.

I'm suggesting that our experience of being human might tell us considerably more about being human than it tells us about all the possible ways of being.

People sometimes report experiences in which their ordinary sense of self seems to dissolve. Such experiences don't prove a universal mind, another dimension, or God.

But they do remind us that even our familiar sense of being a separate self isn't quite as unchangeable as it usually feels.

Which brings me back to my face.

I don't think my face is lying to me.

I think it's doing the best it can with the equipment available.

The problem begins when I mistake its report for a complete inventory of existence.

We spend a great deal of time arguing about what's real.

We look through our limited senses, consult our limited imaginations, and compare notes with other members of a species equipped with essentially the same basic equipment.

Then we announce our conclusions.

Sometimes with remarkable confidence.

I wonder what that confidence would look like to something that experienced the universe in a way we couldn't begin to understand.

Somewhere, if such a creature exists, it might regard us the way we'd regard a person who had never seen the sky.

Only it wouldn't be regarding us.

And it wouldn't be pity.

See?

We can't even get the sentence right.

Keep reading

What If We're Not as Separate as We Think?

The Universe Has Not Asked for Our Review

← Back to the journal