M. J. ELLIS

Field note 028

The Universe Has Not Asked for Our Review

By M. J. Ellis

Let somebody cut me off in traffic and I can learn an astonishing amount about him in three seconds.

He's selfish. He's an idiot. He has no respect for other people. His family probably changes the subject when someone asks how he's doing.

I don't know his name.

I don't know where he's going.

But apparently I've seen enough.

The investigation is complete. The evidence is a blinker.

Of course, when I do something stupid in traffic, the situation is considerably more nuanced.

I didn't realize that was my turn. The lanes were confusing. Somebody had put the sign in a ridiculous place. I was distracted because I have a lot going on, which is an important consideration when evaluating my conduct.

When he does it, he's an asshole.

When I do it, we really need to look at the whole situation.

I find this to be an excellent system. Very fair. Extremely convenient for me.


We do this with practically everything.

Bad weather. Good news. Terrible day. Best thing that ever happened to me.

And most of the time, everyone knows what we mean. If rain ruins your plans, you don't need to explain that your assessment is limited to your personal experience of the afternoon. Nobody wants that conversation. They're wet.

But sometimes I think we forget the qualification was there.

The rain isn't bad. The rain is bad for the thing I wanted to do.

Somewhere else, somebody is standing on a porch watching it come down, relieved that they don't have to drag a hose across the yard again.

Same rain.

Two completely different reviews.

Meanwhile, the rain continues falling, having received no indication that its performance is under evaluation.

I wonder how often we're doing that. Having an experience, deciding how we feel about it, and quietly promoting that feeling to a fact about the universe.

This has inconvenienced me. Something is wrong with reality.

To be fair, I have had afternoons that made a compelling case.


Time makes the whole arrangement even less reliable.

Something happens. A plan collapses. A door closes. You stand there looking at the wreckage of what was supposed to happen and announce that your life has officially gone to shit.

This is understandable. You've put a lot of work into that particular version of the future. You may even have purchased supplies.

Then something else happens.

You meet someone. Discover a different way to live. Find yourself doing something you would never have considered while you were busy trying to force the original plan to cooperate.

Years later, you look back at the disaster and realize your entire life turned on it.

Which is strange, because at the time you were fairly certain it was the end of your entire life.

Apparently the story had continued after you finished reviewing it.

Now, I don't think this means every terrible thing is secretly wonderful.

Some things hurt, and they keep hurting. I have no interest in telling someone their suffering was a thoughtful little gift from the universe. The universe can send a card next time.

Something worthwhile growing out of pain doesn't make the pain itself wonderful, either.

But there are things I once understood one way that I understand differently now. I haven't changed what happened. I've changed how much of the story I can see.

And yet the next time something goes wrong, there I am again.

Standing in the middle of an unfinished event, confidently writing the ending.


People are where this starts bothering me most.

We take something a person did and use it to explain everything they are. Once the label is in place, we don't have to keep looking. We already know what we're dealing with.

Every decent thing they do can now be dismissed as an exception. Or an act. Possibly some elaborate scheme to conceal the fact that our original assessment was correct.

There's something impressive about a conclusion that can survive all available evidence.

Someone can do something cruel. They can also love their children, worry about their mother, feed a stray cat, and occasionally lie awake wondering why they keep fucking things up.

The cruelty still happened.

The person it hurt is still hurt.

But the human being responsible hasn't become less complicated just because we're angry with them.

I know this because I remain an incredibly complicated person whenever I'm the one who did something wrong.

You'd need background information. Childhood experiences. Several conversations. Possibly a diagram.

Other people can apparently be explained with one word shouted through a windshield.

And then, sometimes, we turn that same little machine on ourselves.

I failed at something.

I'm a failure.

I did something shameful.

I am shameful.

I made a mistake.

I am a mistake.

That's a hell of a promotion. One event has somehow acquired authority over the entire person who experienced it.

And what are you supposed to do with I am a mistake?

You can apologize for something you did. You can repair damage, change a habit, learn something, make a different decision tomorrow.

But if the problem is that you exist incorrectly, there's nowhere left to go.

We've turned a thing that happened into a thing we are, then wondered why we can't move past it.


I'm not giving the guy in traffic unlimited access to my sympathy. He still needs to operate his vehicle in a way that allows the rest of us to remain alive.

We have to make judgments. We have to recognize danger, hold people accountable, and occasionally decide that someone is no longer welcome in our lives.

I don't need to understand every detail of a person's childhood before telling them to get the hell out of my house.

But I can know enough to act without knowing everything.

That's the part I keep coming back to.

I can know that something hurt me. I can know that a decision was wrong. I can know that I don't want to go through something again.

What I can't always know is the full size of the thing I'm judging.

How much happened before I arrived. What's going on where I can't see. What will happen after I've confidently announced what it all means.

I have a little patch of the whole thing available to me, and an extraordinary amount of confidence considering the size of the patch.

The universe has not asked for our review.

We've been leaving them anyway.

Five stars. One star. Would not recommend.

I'd like to remember, occasionally, that I haven't seen the whole place.

I might even let the next guy merge.

I'm not promising him five stars.

Keep reading

I’ve Heard Some Things About You

Your Worst Day Is Still Your Worst Day

← Back to the journal