Field note 042
The Universe Has a Lost-and-Found Department
Somewhere, I hope, there is a room containing every version of my life that almost happened.
Not metaphorically. I mean an actual room. Preferably with filing cabinets, fluorescent lighting, and a deeply unpleasant woman named Marge who has been working there since before time existed.
I imagine it looks like the DMV, except instead of renewing your driver's license, you can ask what happened to the version of you who learned to play piano.
Marge doesn't look up.
"Name?"
I tell her.
"Which one?"
"Excuse me?"
She sighs, removes her glasses, and gives me the kind of look normally reserved for people who bring twelve items into the ten-items-or-less lane.
"Which version of you?"
I hadn't considered that.
"All of them, I guess."
She laughs.
Not because I've said something funny.
Because I've said something expensive.
I've been thinking about the lives we don't live.
Not just the big ones. The alternate careers, the people we almost married, the cities we nearly moved to.
I'm talking about the little ones, too.
Somewhere there's a version of me who went to the grocery store on Tuesday instead of Wednesday and met a man who changed his entire life.
There's another who learned Spanish.
One who never discovered heavy metal.
I don't particularly want to meet that last one. I suspect he owns boat shoes.
And somewhere, presumably, there's a version of me who has consistently made sensible decisions, maintained a healthy sleep schedule, and understood the terms of his credit cards before signing anything.
I don't trust him.
He sounds like a narc.
But I wonder about them.
Do they exist in some meaningful sense? Or are they just stories we tell ourselves about doors that were never actually opened?
Because the strange thing about possibility is that we experience it as something real right up until the moment we make a choice.
Before I decide what to eat for lunch, there are a hundred possible lunches.
Afterward, there is one lunch and ninety-nine ghosts.
Usually the surviving lunch is disappointing.
Back at the Lost-and-Found Department, Marge has located my file.
It's enormous.
She wheels it out on a cart that looks like it was borrowed from a hospital morgue.
"You're going to need to narrow this down."
"How many are there?"
"How many what?"
"Versions of me."
She looks at the cart.
Then at me.
Then at the cart again.
"This is Tuesday."
I ask whether I can see the version of myself who became a professional musician.
She opens a drawer.
"Which one?"
Apparently, I became several different kinds of musician.
In one life, I toured the world.
In another, I taught guitar lessons to children who didn't practice.
In a third, I became very successful playing something called progressive bluegrass.
I close that drawer immediately.
There are things a man shouldn't know about himself.
Then I ask about the version of me who never made my worst mistakes.
Marge stops smiling.
For the first time, she seems almost sympathetic.
"Everybody asks for that one."
She slides a folder across the counter.
It's thinner than I expected.
Inside is a photograph of a man who looks like me, only older around the eyes.
He's sitting on a porch.
I can't tell whether he's happy.
I look closer.
There's a second chair beside him, but I can't see who's sitting in it. The photograph ends just before the person comes into view.
"Can you show me the rest?"
"No."
"Why not?"
"Because you didn't ask for the rest. You asked for the man who didn't make your mistakes."
I study his face.
He looks healthy. Comfortable, maybe.
I find myself searching the photograph for evidence that he's better off. Something in his expression. The house behind him. The quality of the furniture.
As if happiness might be determined by porch construction.
"Is he happy?"
Marge shrugs.
"Sometimes."
"Is he happier than me?"
She looks at me for a long moment.
"Would you believe me if I told you?"
I don't answer.
"Can I trade?"
She closes the folder.
"No exchanges."
"Even if I made a mistake?"
"Especially then."
For a moment, I want to argue.
Instead, I ask her to put the photograph away.
She does.
And I find myself watching the drawer close a little more carefully than I intended.
"Anything else?" Marge asks.
I tell her I'd like to see the life where I made all the right decisions.
She stares at me.
Then she reaches beneath the counter and produces a laminated sign.
THERE IS NO SUCH FILE.
"People ask often?"
"We had to laminate it."
I ask whether there's at least a version of me who made better decisions.
"Better for whom?"
"For me."
"Which you?"
I hate when bureaucrats become philosophers.
It's unprofessional.
She opens another drawer and produces three folders.
In one, I took a job I desperately wanted. I lasted eleven months before I began fantasizing about driving my car into a lake.
In another, I married someone I once thought I couldn't live without.
Apparently, I could.
In the third, I avoided an enormous personal disaster.
"That one," I say.
Marge opens the folder.
There's a photograph of me standing beside a car.
"What's wrong with this one?"
"Nothing."
"Then why are you looking at me like that?"
"Because you're going to ask what happened six months later."
I look at the photograph again.
"Did something happen six months later?"
"Something always happens six months later."
She puts the folder away.
I begin to suspect the universe has a fairly aggressive return policy.
"Can I ask you something?"
"You've been doing that for twenty minutes."
"Do you ever get people who are satisfied with their lives?"
"Occasionally."
"What do they ask for?"
"Directions to the exit."
That bothers me more than it should.
I look at the enormous cart containing all the people I might have been.
Every drawer contains another road I didn't take.
Another career. Another relationship. Another city. Another Tuesday.
And every one of those lives looks remarkably appealing from this side of the filing cabinet.
No dirty dishes.
No overdue bills.
No mysterious smell coming from the car because some small mammal found a way into the air intake and decided it was an appropriate place to conduct his final affairs.
An unlived life has never had a Tuesday.
I wonder whether the people in those folders ever imagine being me.
Whether the successful musician occasionally wishes he'd stayed home.
Whether the sensible man with the excellent credit score sometimes wonders what would have happened if he'd been a little less sensible.
Whether the man on the porch ever thinks about the mistakes he didn't make.
I ask Marge.
"Do they?"
"Do they what?"
"Wonder about me?"
She looks at the cart.
"Of course."
I hadn't expected that.
"What do they think?"
She reaches for another laminated sign.
THAT INFORMATION IS NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS.
I think Marge may have a laminator somewhere behind the counter.
I also think she enjoys using it.
Eventually, she tells me the department is closing.
"Can I take anything with me?"
"No."
"Not even a photograph?"
"No."
"Can I at least find out which version of me made the most money?"
She looks at me over her glasses.
"That information is restricted."
"Why?"
"Because you people get weird about it."
Fair.
I start toward the exit.
Then I stop.
"One more question."
She closes her eyes.
I can tell I'm becoming a problem.
"What happens to all these lives?"
"The ones nobody chooses?"
"Yeah."
She considers this.
"Nothing."
"Nothing?"
"They were possibilities. Not promises."
I look back at the endless rows of filing cabinets.
All those almosts.
All those maybes.
All those versions of me who never had to figure out what to do next.
And then I realize something.
Every single one of them has the same problem.
They're not here.
I am.
Which means, for better or worse, I'm the one who gets to find out what happens.
I turn toward the door.
"Wait," Marge says.
I look back.
She's holding a small cardboard box.
"Almost forgot. You left something."
"What is it?"
"Your potential."
I stare at the box.
It's considerably smaller than I expected.
"That's all of it?"
"That's what you've got left today."
"Today?"
She taps a sign beside the exit.
UNUSED POTENTIAL DOES NOT ROLL OVER.
"That's a terrible policy."
"Take it up with management."
"Who's management?"
Marge looks at the ceiling.
Then at me.
"Nobody's ever gotten a straight answer."
She slides the box across the counter.
"Now get out. You're holding up the line."