Field note 051
We Keep Using the Same Word
The other day, my mother said something that made me sad.
Not angry. Not offended. Sad.
My grandmother had just passed away, and my mother was expressing the comfort she found in knowing where my grandmother had gone.
And then she expressed her fear about where I was going.
Not geographically. My mother knows where I live.
She was talking about eternity.
She believed she knew where my grandmother was, and she was afraid that someday I wouldn't be there.
And I could tell she meant it.
That's what bothered me.
Not that she believed something different from what I believe. I've never had much trouble with people believing things I don't. Hell, I regularly entertain ideas that I don't believe myself. Sometimes just to see what happens when I let them run around unsupervised.
What bothered me was that she was afraid for me.
And somewhere in that conversation, I had the uncomfortable sensation that I understood God better than she did.
That's a hell of a thing to think about your own mother.
It's also a hell of a thing to think about God.
Because the moment you become certain you understand the infinite better than somebody else, you should probably consider the possibility that you've misunderstood something rather important about infinity.
Experience deserves humility.
I wrote that in God's Name Is Gerald, and apparently I'm not exempt from my own advice.
My grandmother left her Bible to my wife.
When we opened it, we found a passage bookmarked in Luke.
It was the part where Jesus explains to his disciples why he speaks in parables.
I have no idea why my grandmother marked that particular passage. Maybe it meant something profound to her. Maybe she'd simply stopped reading there.
I'm not going to pretend I received a secret message from beyond the grave.
But it got me thinking.
Jesus tells his disciples that they've been given knowledge of the mysteries of the kingdom of God. Others hear those mysteries through parables, with the troubling suggestion that hearing doesn't necessarily mean understanding.
And I started wondering about the conversations that never made it into the Bible.
Not necessarily secret teachings. Not some elaborate conspiracy involving monks hiding scrolls under the Vatican.
Just conversations.
The ones that happened when the crowds went home.
The questions his disciples asked when they didn't understand something. The explanations that followed. The discussions that probably wandered well beyond whatever subject had started them.
The man spent his ministry talking to people.
We have a handful of books.
Surely there was more to the conversation.
And then I started wondering whether some of what he was trying to communicate could even be adequately preserved in words.
I've developed a habit in my writing.
I'll encounter an idea that makes something ordinary suddenly seem very strange, and then I'll spend an unreasonable amount of time trying to make somebody else experience the same discomfort.
I'm not especially interested in telling readers what to think.
I want them to encounter the question that disturbed me.
For example, imagine an intelligent civilization that evolved without eyes.
They might develop mathematics, technology, philosophy, and elaborate methods for studying electromagnetic radiation. They might know an enormous amount about the universe.
But they would never have experienced the color blue.
Now ask yourself how much of reality you're missing simply because you were never equipped to perceive it.
See?
That's the part I want.
Not the explanation.
The moment the familiar world becomes a little less familiar.
And it occurred to me that perhaps some of Jesus' parables worked in a similar way.
Not simply as stories containing moral instructions, but as invitations to examine assumptions people didn't even realize they were making.
Maybe the point wasn't always to provide an answer.
Maybe sometimes the point was to make the old answer stop working.
I'm not claiming Jesus and I are doing the same thing. Our aims and circumstances are hardly comparable.
I'm simply beginning to appreciate what a powerful tool a story can be when you're trying to communicate something that can't be handed from one mind to another like a grocery list.
Which brings me back to my mother.
I think we were using the same word and imagining very different things.
God.
Three letters.
A rather ambitious amount of meaning to cram into them.
For her, God is inseparable from a lifetime of faith, scripture, salvation, judgment, and the possibility that someone she loves might be lost.
And in this case, that someone was me.
My mother wasn't trying to hurt me. She was expressing a fear born of love. In her understanding of the universe, something terrible could happen to me after I die, and she desperately doesn't want that to happen.
I understand that.
What I couldn't do was make her understand why I didn't share the fear.
The strange thing is, I don't actually disagree with anything Jesus taught.
It's a lot of the ideas and beliefs that have become associated with Christianity that I struggle with.
And there are plenty of those ideas I have room for, even when I'm not convinced of them myself.
But there's one in particular that I cannot seem to reconcile with the idea of a loving God.
Eternal torment.
I know Jesus spoke about judgment. I'm not pretending otherwise. But Christians have spent centuries disagreeing about what that judgment ultimately means.
And the particular idea I struggle with is not simply the possibility that someone who rejects God might cease to exist. Not punishment followed by an opportunity to understand, change, or become something better.
I'm talking about the idea that God would create a conscious being, allow that being to exist for a finite amount of time, and then subject it to conscious suffering for all eternity because it failed to meet the necessary conditions.
Forever.
Not a thousand years. Not a billion.
Forever.
And I'm supposed to understand that as justice.
But I keep encountering a question I can't get around.
If a human being deliberately subjected another human being to endless suffering, with no possibility of redemption, we would call that person unimaginably cruel.
Why would the same behavior become perfectly good simply because God was doing it?
And if God is all-powerful, why would eternal suffering be necessary in the first place?
If his desire is to redeem his creation, yet some of that creation must suffer forever, has he accomplished what he intended?
If this is the only way he can accomplish his will, in what sense is he the highest power?
I know there are Christians who reject eternal conscious torment entirely. Some believe the unredeemed eventually cease to exist. Others believe even divine judgment ultimately serves reconciliation.
I'm not suggesting Christianity has never wrestled with these questions.
I'm wondering why we sometimes treat the most terrifying answers as though they're the only ones worthy of faith.
And I know the argument about free will.
That God allows us to reject him.
All right.
But why must death make that rejection irreversible?
Why would an infinitely patient being run out of patience?
Why would a God who knows absolutely everything about a person—their experiences, their limitations, their fears, the circumstances of their birth, every misunderstanding that ever shaped their thinking—be unable to bring that person to understanding?
Especially given eternity to work with.
I don't pretend to have the answers.
But I don't think these are unreasonable questions.
And then I think about my mother.
My mother loves me. She knows me. She would never willingly subject me to eternal suffering, no matter how badly I disappointed her.
So I find myself wondering something that I wish I could ask without causing her more pain.
If God loves me even more than my mother does, why is my mother trying to save me from something God would be willing to do to me?
That's the part I can't make fit.
And it's the part I wish she could see.
Not because I need to win an argument.
Because I love her.
And I don't want her spending the rest of her life terrified that the God she worships might someday torture her son.
Of course, there's an uncomfortable problem with my position.
It's still my position.
My understanding of God has been moving in a direction that feels increasingly expansive to me.
I find myself suspicious of any description of the infinite that fits too neatly inside a human explanation.
I wonder whether we confuse our interpretations of God with God himself.
Whether we mistake the language we've inherited for the reality it's trying to describe.
Whether we've spent so long arguing about which description is correct that we've forgotten we're attempting to describe something we claim exceeds human understanding in the first place.
But those are my interpretations, too.
I don't get to escape the problem simply by recognizing it.
I have my own limitations. My own assumptions. My own experiences that I mistake for universal truths.
I could be wrong about all sorts of things.
Probably am.
And maybe my mother has encountered something through her faith that I haven't.
Maybe there are things she understands that I don't.
That's a possibility I have to leave room for if I expect her to leave room for mine.
Experience deserves humility.
It's easy to write that sentence.
It's considerably harder to live inside it when someone you love is afraid.
Perhaps that's something I've been learning through writing.
You cannot give another person a realization.
You can explain it. Describe it. Build a little story around it and hope they wander into the same strange corner of thought where you found it.
But you can't make it happen.
And if it does happen, there's no guarantee they'll discover what you discovered.
They might see something you missed.
Which brings me back to the parables.
Maybe Jesus understood something about the difference between telling someone what is true and helping them encounter a truth for themselves.
Maybe some things have to be experienced before they can be understood.
I don't know.
I wasn't there.
And I don't know what my grandmother saw in that passage in Luke, either.
I don't know what Jesus said to his disciples when nobody else was listening. And I certainly don't know everything my mother has experienced through her faith.
I only know that my grandmother died, my mother found comfort in believing she knew where she'd gone, and then expressed fear that I might never join her there.
And somewhere in all of that, I found myself looking at God from another angle.
I wish I could show my mother what I'm seeing.
Not because I need her to agree with me.
But because I would love for her to find the same comfort in whatever awaits me that she has found in what she believes awaits my grandmother.
Perhaps she never will.
Perhaps I'll discover something that changes my own understanding.
Either way, I don't want our remaining time together defined by fear of what comes afterward.
Because whatever God is, whatever happens when we die, whatever either of us has understood correctly or misunderstood completely, there's something I know about my mother.
She loves me.
And I love her.
We may not mean exactly the same thing when we say God.
But when we say we love each other, I don't think either of us needs a parable to understand.
And maybe that's where God is.
In the one thing neither of us has to explain to the other.
There's a parable for you.