Field note 022
Who's Performing?
By M. J. Ellis
Every room contains at least two versions of you: the one who entered and the one who noticed who was already there.
Sometimes there's a third version who immediately regrets entering.
I have quite a few versions of myself.
There's the one who talks to strangers. The one who would rather not. The one who can hold an entire conversation about the nature of consciousness, and the one who has absolutely nothing to contribute when somebody asks what I want for dinner.
Apparently, these are all the same person.
Which raises an interesting question.
Who's performing?
We tend to talk about authenticity as though there's one genuine version of ourselves buried underneath all the others.
Somewhere beneath the manners, the social expectations, the nervous laughter, and the voice we use when answering an unexpected phone call, there's supposed to be a pure, unfiltered you.
Find that person, we're told. Be that person.
All the time, apparently.
I can't imagine anything more exhausting.
For one thing, which one is it?
Am I more authentically myself when I'm being thoughtful and philosophical, or when I'm laughing at something so stupid that explaining it would make the situation worse?
When I'm confident? When I'm frightened? When I'm affectionate? When I'm being a complete pain in the ass?
I have compelling evidence for all four.
And I don't see why any one of them gets to declare itself the real me and evict the others.
Think about the way you behave around different people.
You probably speak differently to your mother than you do to your friends. Differently to your employer than to your partner. Differently to a stranger who has just complimented your shirt than to someone who has inexplicably decided to explain your own job to you.
We call some of this code-switching. Some of it manners. Some of it professionalism.
And sometimes we call it wearing a mask.
But a mask suggests there's something false about what we're showing.
Is there?
If I'm playful with one person and serious with another, which interaction was the lie?
Maybe neither.
Maybe both people brought something different out of me.
Maybe I contain more than one thing.
This would certainly explain why I have so much trouble making decisions.
I think identity is something we can play with.
Not necessarily because there's nothing solid underneath it, but because there's so much available to us.
Consider a musician.
The same person can perform something furious, something tender, something ridiculous, and something heartbreaking. Nobody insists that only one of those performances reveals the musician's true nature.
We understand that the artist has a range.
Then we go home and expect ourselves to have one personality.
Preferably one that can be summarized in a dating profile.
Adventurous. Thoughtful. Enjoys travel. Occasionally consumed by the incomprehensible fact of existence.
Swipe right.
I wonder how many parts of ourselves we leave unexplored because we've already decided what kind of person we are.
We say things like, "I'm not the sort of person who does that."
Sometimes that's a useful boundary.
Sometimes it's just a description we wrote ten years ago and haven't bothered to update.
Of course, there is such a thing as pretending.
People lie. People manipulate. People manufacture personalities to get what they want.
I'm not suggesting that every performance is authentic simply because somebody performed it.
But I think there's a difference between pretending to possess a quality you don't have and choosing to express a quality you do.
You can be genuinely kind without being kind every second of the day.
You can be brave while feeling terrified.
You can be funny without turning every funeral into an open-mic night.
In fact, I'd recommend against that last one.
The point is that choosing how to express yourself doesn't automatically make the expression dishonest.
Sometimes the choice is precisely what makes it meaningful.
And then there's the strange business of becoming someone new.
We talk about personal growth as though we're uncovering something that was always there.
Maybe sometimes we are.
But surely we also create things.
We learn to enjoy things we once disliked. We develop interests we never imagined having. We discover abilities through practice. We become more patient, less patient, more curious, more careful.
We change.
If the person I become tomorrow isn't identical to the person I was yesterday, does that mean one of us was pretending?
I hope not.
I'd hate to discover I've been impersonating myself for forty years.
Perhaps authenticity isn't about finding one permanent character and refusing to break character.
Perhaps it's about knowing what you're doing when you step onto the stage.
Sometimes you're expressing something you've always felt. Sometimes you're trying something you've never done before. Sometimes you're playing a part just to find out whether you enjoy being that person.
And here's where it gets interesting.
What if the performance changes you?
What if you decide to be brave, despite never having thought of yourself as brave, and afterward you discover that bravery is now something you can do?
What if you start behaving like a more patient person and, through the deeply irritating process of practicing patience, actually become one?
At what point does trying become being?
I don't know. But I suspect the distinction is considerably less important than we make it.
We aren't necessarily uncovering a finished person buried somewhere inside us.
We might be making one.
And remaking one.
Over and over, using whatever we've learned, whatever we've experienced, and whatever new possibilities happen to catch our attention.
I used to think there was probably one true version of me waiting behind a curtain.
Now I suspect there's an entire cast back there.
Some of them are very talented.
Some of them should probably not be allowed near a microphone.
And some haven't even been invented yet.
Which means the question isn't simply who's performing.
It's who might I become if I decide to try a different part?
After all, the performance isn't necessarily a disguise.
Sometimes it's how the performer comes into existence.
Read next
Explore a book
For a closer look at perception and the assumptions behind experience, read a sample of The Book You Are Not Supposed to Finish.
What did this bring up for you?
A question, a disagreement, a story of your own? I’d like to hear it. You don’t need to have it all figured out.
Send me your thoughts → or visit the contact page.